pinbong
Junior Member
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2010
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Chinese
- Home Country
- China
- Current Location
- China
"Either" or "Too"?? "Aren't they" or "Are they"?(tag)
Hi, teachers:
1. I know that "either" is used in negative sentences. But since it's "used to indicate a similarity or link with a statement just made. "(oxford dictionary), what if the previously made statement is a positive sentence but the verb of the second sentence is negative??
Just like the statements I made in my another post:
I sort of find "too" acceptable too. because the second sentence is following a positive statement.
2. Some of my thoughts regarding "tags" are posted in the following paragraph . Teachers, please tell me if I understand it correctly.
I know not all tags negate the preceding sentences. Sometimes they are "positive". My understanding is, in such cases, "positive tags" are actually not regular "tags". Instead , they're new questions, and they have totally different connotations with the regular "negative tags"? Do I understand it correctly??
Example:
[edited to redress the typos previously made.]
Maybe the second sentence sounds odd to native speakers. But I do remember hearing it said by native speakers too. Another example being:
Does this one sound odd to native speakers too?
Many thanks in advance.
Hi, teachers:
1. I know that "either" is used in negative sentences. But since it's "used to indicate a similarity or link with a statement just made. "(oxford dictionary), what if the previously made statement is a positive sentence but the verb of the second sentence is negative??
Just like the statements I made in my another post:
The sentences sound awkward. (positive sentence.)
And I assume they are not precise either. ("either" or "too"?)
I sort of find "too" acceptable too. because the second sentence is following a positive statement.
2. Some of my thoughts regarding "tags" are posted in the following paragraph . Teachers, please tell me if I understand it correctly.
I know not all tags negate the preceding sentences. Sometimes they are "positive". My understanding is, in such cases, "positive tags" are actually not regular "tags". Instead , they're new questions, and they have totally different connotations with the regular "negative tags"? Do I understand it correctly??
Example:
[edited to redress the typos previously made.]
I assume they are not precise either, are they?
(regular negative tag. rhetorical. Suggesting the speaker is sure of the statement made and just want to confirm it. )
I assume they are not precise either. Aren't they?
(My understanding is: Rigorously speaking, this is not a tag, but a new question. Should use a period to stop the preceding sentence and capitalize the second question. In such cases, the speaker is not sure of the first statement made and is trying to get serious answers from his/her companions. )
Maybe the second sentence sounds odd to native speakers. But I do remember hearing it said by native speakers too. Another example being:
This sentence sounds odd. Does it??(not rhetorical. The speaker is not sure of the first statement and expect an answer from his/her companion)
Does this one sound odd to native speakers too?
Many thanks in advance.
Last edited: