Mairi
Member
- Joined
- Nov 1, 2010
- Member Type
- English Teacher
- Native Language
- English
- Home Country
- UK
- Current Location
- Netherlands
What are the basic rules for when we use 'some' and 'any'?
From looking at this passage..
A. There's some milk in the fridge and there are some cakes in the larder.
B. Have you any bread?
A. No, there isn't any bread.
B. Are there any scones, then?
A. Yes, there are some in the tin.
I would say that the basic rules for when we use 'some' and 'any' is that we use 'some' in positive sentences and we use 'any' in negative sentences or questions where we are expecting a 'no' answer.
However, is it correct to say "Can I have some notebooks for my students?" - Yes. Therefore what is the exception to this rule?
The exception is that we use 'some' when requesting using 'can' in sentences when we are unsure of the answer we will receive.
:?:I am trying to find explanations about the following sentences..
a. I like some pop music.
b. I like any pop music.
c. I don't like some pop music.
d. I don't like any pop music.
I have been told to look up Lewis and Hill - Practical Techniques for Language Learning, for answers. However, unfortunately I am unable to find the answers I am looking for as my library does not have this book and cannot order it in. I have ordered it online but with the backlog of orders I will not be receiving it in time before the start of my CELTA course. Does anybody reading this post have this book and is able to tell me what Lewis and Hill say about 'some' and 'any'?
Also, if anyone has any corrections to the first part of my answer that would be great.
Many thanks.
From looking at this passage..
A. There's some milk in the fridge and there are some cakes in the larder.
B. Have you any bread?
A. No, there isn't any bread.
B. Are there any scones, then?
A. Yes, there are some in the tin.
I would say that the basic rules for when we use 'some' and 'any' is that we use 'some' in positive sentences and we use 'any' in negative sentences or questions where we are expecting a 'no' answer.
However, is it correct to say "Can I have some notebooks for my students?" - Yes. Therefore what is the exception to this rule?
The exception is that we use 'some' when requesting using 'can' in sentences when we are unsure of the answer we will receive.
:?:I am trying to find explanations about the following sentences..
a. I like some pop music.
b. I like any pop music.
c. I don't like some pop music.
d. I don't like any pop music.
I have been told to look up Lewis and Hill - Practical Techniques for Language Learning, for answers. However, unfortunately I am unable to find the answers I am looking for as my library does not have this book and cannot order it in. I have ordered it online but with the backlog of orders I will not be receiving it in time before the start of my CELTA course. Does anybody reading this post have this book and is able to tell me what Lewis and Hill say about 'some' and 'any'?
Also, if anyone has any corrections to the first part of my answer that would be great.
Many thanks.