Verona_82
Senior Member
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2010
- Member Type
- Other
- Native Language
- Russian
- Home Country
- Russian Federation
- Current Location
- Ukraine
Hello!
Revising the Past Perfect, I got mixed up by a couple of examples in my CPE book:
(1) Before he read the letter he took a deep breath (NOT HAD TAKEN)
(2) After he had done the washing up, he collapsed in a chair (NOT DID)
(3) When we had galloped up the stairs, we discovered that he window had been broken (NOT GALLOPED)
I cannot get a handle on the use of conjunctions with the Past Perfect.
1. The person took a breath before he read the letter, why can't I say "had taken"?
2. the person first did the laundry and then collapsed in a chair; isn't this "had done" redundant here? The actions are listed in their chronological order, so why the Past Perfect?
3. Again, they galloped up the stairs and then did the next action. The action order isn't reversed. Is saying "when we galloped.... we discovered" such a dreadful mistake? :-?
I'd appreciate it if anyone could comment on that.
Thank you in advance!
Revising the Past Perfect, I got mixed up by a couple of examples in my CPE book:
(1) Before he read the letter he took a deep breath (NOT HAD TAKEN)
(2) After he had done the washing up, he collapsed in a chair (NOT DID)
(3) When we had galloped up the stairs, we discovered that he window had been broken (NOT GALLOPED)
I cannot get a handle on the use of conjunctions with the Past Perfect.
1. The person took a breath before he read the letter, why can't I say "had taken"?
2. the person first did the laundry and then collapsed in a chair; isn't this "had done" redundant here? The actions are listed in their chronological order, so why the Past Perfect?
3. Again, they galloped up the stairs and then did the next action. The action order isn't reversed. Is saying "when we galloped.... we discovered" such a dreadful mistake? :-?
I'd appreciate it if anyone could comment on that.
Thank you in advance!