zorank
Junior Member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Member Type
- Academic
- Native Language
- Croatian
- Home Country
- Croatia
- Current Location
- Sweden
Hello,
I have the following problem with ?THE/0? use of the definite article. This problem haunts me frequently in my scientific writing since instances of it can be rather subtle. (My native tounge is of ?THE/0? Slavic origin and we do not have ?THESE/THE/0? articles.) I can provide more examples as we progress in the discussion (hopefully, hope someone will try to help).
In the construct THE + PLURAL NOUN it is not clear to me whether this refers to the whole set or just a subgroup of the set. For example, assume that we are in a room with a table. There is a bowl of apples on the table. I tell you:
(1) “Please take the apples”.
(2) “Please take apples”.
How would you understand (1) versus (2). Would you take them all, or just a few.
You reply
(1) “Apples are good. Thanks for offering them”.
(2) “The apples are good. Thanks for offering them”.
How should I understand (1) versus (2) (i.e. are you going to snatch them all or not)?
Regards
Zoran
p.s. Also, I would be grateful if someone could comment on which choices to make for ?...?.
I have the following problem with ?THE/0? use of the definite article. This problem haunts me frequently in my scientific writing since instances of it can be rather subtle. (My native tounge is of ?THE/0? Slavic origin and we do not have ?THESE/THE/0? articles.) I can provide more examples as we progress in the discussion (hopefully, hope someone will try to help).
In the construct THE + PLURAL NOUN it is not clear to me whether this refers to the whole set or just a subgroup of the set. For example, assume that we are in a room with a table. There is a bowl of apples on the table. I tell you:
(1) “Please take the apples”.
(2) “Please take apples”.
How would you understand (1) versus (2). Would you take them all, or just a few.
You reply
(1) “Apples are good. Thanks for offering them”.
(2) “The apples are good. Thanks for offering them”.
How should I understand (1) versus (2) (i.e. are you going to snatch them all or not)?
Regards
Zoran
p.s. Also, I would be grateful if someone could comment on which choices to make for ?...?.
Last edited: