questions about a memo

Status
Not open for further replies.

ziawj2

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
MEMO

TO: Department Managers
FROM: Mackintosh Smith
DATE: April 3, 2012
SUBJECT: In-Service Computer Class
From April 28, Computer Class will be held on Saturdays for two months. There will be 2 groups: intermediate level and advanced level.
Please encourage your staff to attend one of the sessions. All teaching materials will be provided.
Please send me the names of all interested staff by next Friday. These staff will take a test the week before May.
In the above memo, I have some questions about two words and a sentence:
1. Department Managers
Does "Division Managers" have the same meaning as "Department Managers"? Ifso, which one is more natural?
2. Please encourage your staff to attend one of the sessions.
Are the words “groups” and “levels” more proper than “sessions”? Because “groups” and “levels” are mensioned above. Do you think so?
3. Please send me the names of all interested staff by next Friday. These staff will take a test the week before May.
I thought the word "me" would make readers feel puzzled because they had to look through back to find out who is "me", so I preferred changing it to the person's name.
In the previous sentence, "staff" has been mentioned, so I changed it to "they" to be coherent. And finally, "the week before May" also will take readers some time to know when they will take a test, so I changed it to "the last week in April".
I made the following change:
Please send Mackintosh Smith the names of the staff interested in by next Friday. They will take a test in the last week of April.
What is your opinion? And besides these, are there any other problems in the memo? Thank you!
 
Last edited:

5jj

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
Czech Republic
Current Location
Czech Republic
1. Department Managers
Does "Division Managers" have the same meaning as "Department Managers"? Ifso, which one is more natural?
Only people in your company can answer that. Who is Mackintosh writing to? Are they called 'Department Managers' or 'Division Managers' in your company?

2. Please encourage your staff to attend one of the sessions.
Are the words “groups” and “levels” more proper than “sessions”? Because “groups” and “levels” are men[STRIKE]s[/STRIKE]tioned above. Do you think so?
What Mackintosh has written seems fine to me.

3. Please send me the names of all interested staff by next Friday. These staff will take a test the week before May.
I thought the word "me" would make readers feel puzzled because they had to look through back to find out who is "me", so I preferred changing it to the person's name.
You don't seem to have much faith in your staff if you feel that they have already forgotten who the memo is from.

In the previous sentence, "staff" has been mentioned, so I changed it to "they" to be coherent.
Not necessary

And finally, "the week before May" also will take readers some time to know when they will take a test, so I changed it to "the last week in April".

OK, 'the last week in April' is clearer
5
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top