[Grammar] Who is calling Ali?, Can you guess Ali is subj or obj?

Status
Not open for further replies.

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
John is calling Ali.
1. Who is calling Ali? (answer: John)
2. Who is calling John? (answer: Ali)
3. Whom is calling John? (answer: Ali)
But I think we can't say:
4. Whom is calling Ali? (answer: John)
Because 'whom' is only for objects. Am I right?
 
Last edited:

Preceptor

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2011
Member Type
Retired Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
'Who is calling Ali?' This asks the identity of the person calling Ali.

'Who is calling, Ali?' This asks Ali the identity of the person calling.

'Whom is Ali calling?' This asks the identity of the person Ali is calling.

'Whom is Ali calling, John?' This asks John the identity of the person Ali is calling.

'Who' is nominative; 'whom' is objective. You cannot use 'who' as the direct object, and you cannot use 'whom' as the subject.
 

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
'Who is calling Ali?' This asks the identity of the person calling Ali.

'Who is calling, Ali?' This asks Ali the identity of the person calling.

'Whom is Ali calling?' This asks the identity of the person Ali is calling.

'Whom is Ali calling, John?' This asks John the identity of the person Ali is calling.

'Who' is nominative; 'whom' is objective. You cannot use 'who' as the direct object, and you cannot use 'whom' as the subject.
Yes, but my questin is something else.
The sentence of which we have some questions is this: John is calling Ali.
My question is that why the structure is the same whether the answer is John (sunject) or Ali (object)
Please see my post again. There isn't any comma in.
 

5jj

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
Czech Republic
Current Location
Czech Republic
John is calling Ali.
1. Who is calling Ali? (answer: John):tick:
2. Who is calling John? (answer: Ali) If the situation is that John is calling Ali, then you cannot ask this question. Nobody is calling John.
3. Whom is calling John? (answer: Ali) Incorrect English. - We could ask, "Whom is John calling?" - "Ali". However, most people these days would ask, 'Who is John calling?'
But I think we can't say:
4. Whom is calling Ali? (answer: John)This is incorrect English
Because 'whom' is only for objects. Am I right? Yes, and it's very formal.
5
 

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
My question is that why [is] the structure [STRIKE]is[/STRIKE] the same whether the answer is John (subject) or Ali (object)

'John' and 'Who" are the subject (SUBJ), 'whom' is the object (OBJ):

SUBJ + VERB + OBJ
Who is calling Ali?
John is calling Ali.
John is calling whom?
Who is calling whom?

OBJ + AUX + SUBJ + VERB
Whom is John calling?
Whom is who calling?
 

5jj

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
Czech Republic
Current Location
Czech Republic
I agree with everything Soup wrote in her last past. I merely note that "Whom is who calling?", while grammaticaly correct, is very unlikely to be seen/heard, in my opinion.
 

Tdol

No Longer With Us (RIP)
Staff member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Native Language
British English
Home Country
UK
Current Location
Japan
My question is that why the structure is the same whether the answer is John (sunject) or Ali (object)

It's not- only the first question is correct in your post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top