Retired English Teacher
In the sentence "I regard Peter as patriotic/as a patriot", is "as patriotic/as a patriot" a complement to the object "Peter," or an adverb modifying the verb "regard"? Thank you very much.
***** NOT A TEACHER *****
1. What a coincidence. (Or is it?) I was recently doing some research for another thread when I found an article about a sentence similar to yours.
2. One of my favorite books * says this: "An objective complement (my emphasis) with the introductory as is sometimes related in meaning to an adverbial element."
a. Its example: "They regarded him as an honest man." The book claims that "as an honest man" shows "how they regarded him."
b. The same book then gives this sentence: "He was regarded as a vagabond." It analyzes this sentence as:
"He was regarded as a vagabond [is regarded]."
a. I think that most people would consider " as a patriot" to be an objective complement of "Peter."
b. But, if we accept that book's reasoning, "as a patriot" gives somewhat of an adverbial "flavor" to the sentence.
That is, it explains HOW you regard Peter. Maybe that book would analyze it as:
"I regard Peter as a patriot [is regarded].
* English Review Grammar (1940) by Mr. Walter Kay Smart, pages 138 and 227.
Last edited by TheParser; 08-Sep-2012 at 16:19.