Which is right; semi-colon or colon?

Status
Not open for further replies.

eipjoo

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2012
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
Daylight began to forsake the red-room; it was past four o’clock, and the beclouded afternoon was tending to drear twilight. I heard the rain still beating continuously on the staircase window, and the wind howling in the grove behind the hall; I grew by degrees cold as a stone, and then my courage sank. My habitual mood of humiliation, self-doubt, forlorn depression, fell damp on the embers of my decaying ire. All said I was wicked, and perhaps I might be so:?:; what thought had I been but just conceiving of starving myself to death? That certainly was a crime: and was I fit to die? Or was the vault under the chancel of Gateshead Church an inviting bourne? In such vault I had been told did Mr. Reed lie buried; and led by this thought to recall his idea, I dwelt on it with gathering dread. (Jane Eyre)

**
The highlighted punctuation is semi-colon in Gutenberg eBook, and colon in Penguin Books. Which is proper, or more proper in the context?
 

Raymott

VIP Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
Australia
Current Location
Australia
Daylight began to forsake the red-room; it was past four o’clock, and the beclouded afternoon was tending to drear twilight. I heard the rain still beating continuously on the staircase window, and the wind howling in the grove behind the hall; I grew by degrees cold as a stone, and then my courage sank. My habitual mood of humiliation, self-doubt, forlorn depression, fell damp on the embers of my decaying ire. All said I was wicked, and perhaps I might be so:?:; what thought had I been but just conceiving of starving myself to death? That certainly was a crime: and was I fit to die? Or was the vault under the chancel of Gateshead Church an inviting bourne? In such vault I had been told did Mr. Reed lie buried; and led by this thought to recall his idea, I dwelt on it with gathering dread. (Jane Eyre)

**
The highlighted punctuation is semi-colon in Gutenberg eBook, and colon in Penguin Books. Which is proper, or more proper in the context?
There are four examples of sentences joined with colons or semicolons in this short paragraph. That would be uncommon in modern English. There are justifications for either in the one you've queried.
Are you sure you've copied the clause after the semicolon correctly? It seems to mean, "what thought had I been [STRIKE]but[/STRIKE] just conceiving but of starving myself to death?"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top