He's retired

Status
Not open for further replies.

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
- What does he do?
- He's retired, but he said that he ... some undercover work for the communications.
a) has done
b) does
c) did
d) is done
e) is doing
.
.
.
Would you please tell me which option is the best?
Thanks,
ata
 

emsr2d2

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 28, 2009
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
UK
Current Location
UK
- What does he do?
- He's retired, but he said that he ... some undercover work for the communications.

a) has done
b) does
c) did
d) is done
e) is doing



Would you please tell me which option is the best?
Thanks,

ata

Without any further context, a), b), c) and e) all make grammatically correct sentences. However, if we take "What does he do?" as the clue, then b) is the only correct answer as it's the only one in the simple present, the same tense as the question.
 

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
Without any further context, a), b), c) and e) all make grammatically correct sentences. However, if we take "What does he do?" as the clue, then b) is the only correct answer as it's the only one in the simple present, the same tense as the question.

Would you please consider this rule I've found in a grammar book:
When the reporting verb is in past, the following verb:
In formal English: is in the past.
and
In less formal English: can be in present.
This is why I've chosen 'did'
 

Love Teaching

Member
Joined
May 26, 2013
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
NOT A NATIVE TEACHER

Sample context:
It's you, me and Tom.

1)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I do some undercover work for the communications.
After some days, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him the other day. Now he's retired, but he said that he does some undercover work for the communications.
This is reported speech. Since it's still true, no back-shift is required.

2)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I do some undercover work for the communications.
After some months, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him some months ago. Now he's retired, but he said that he did some undercover work for the communications.
Back-shift is required and there is this sense that he doesn't do it anymore.

3)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I did some undercover work for the communications.
Some days later, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him the other day. Now he's retired, but he said that he had done some undercover work for the communications.
 

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
NOT A NATIVE TEACHER

Sample context:
It's you, me and Tom.

1)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I do some undercover work for the communications.
After some days, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him the other day. Now he's retired, but he said that he does some undercover work for the communications.
This is reported speech. Since it's still true, no back-shift is required.

2)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I do some undercover work for the communications.
After some months, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him some months ago. Now he's retired, but he said that he did some undercover work for the communications.
Back-shift is required and there is this sense that he doesn't do it anymore.

3)
While I am walking in the park, I see Tom. I have small talk with Tom and ask him about his life and job.
Me: Hey Tom. How's it going man?
Tom: Fine, finally I'm retired. But, as you know, I did some undercover work for the communications.
Some days later, you see me and ask me about Tom (probably a mutual friend).
You: What does Tom do?
Me: I saw him the other day. Now he's retired, but he said that he had done some undercover work for the communications.

Yes dude thanks, but it's written in Digest that in formal English after a past reporting verb, the following verb is in past too (when the action is still true)
And in less formal English you can use present too.
 

emsr2d2

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 28, 2009
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
UK
Current Location
UK
Which book did you find this in?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top