1. ## every

Hello, everyone
Please tell me what the following sentences mean. Thank you.

1.Students don't go to school every Monday.
a) Sometimes students don't go to school on Monday, but sometimes they do.
b) Whenever there is a Monday, students don't go to school.

2.Students don't go to school on Mondays.
a) Sometimes students don't go to school on Monday, but sometimes they do.
b) Whenever there is a Monday, students don't go to school.

2. ## Re: every

Lisa, what is your thinking on this?

What do you see as the important difference(s)?
Would 1 change for you if it were "Every Monday, students don't go to school"?

3. ## Re: every

Originally Posted by Barb_D
Lisa, what is your thinking on this?

What do you see as the important difference(s)?
Would 1 change for you if it were "Every Monday, students don't go to school"?

Hi, Barb
I just don't know what exactly Sentence 1 and 2 mean. It puzzles me whether they mean the same or not.

No. I think " Every Monday, students don't go to school" means the same as " Students don't go to school every Monday."

4. ## Re: every

Originally Posted by lisa666
Hello, everyone
Please tell me what the following sentences mean. Thank you.

1.Students don't go to school every Monday.
a) Sometimes students don't go to school on Monday, but sometimes they do.
b) Whenever there is a Monday, students don't go to school.

2.Students don't go to school on Mondays.
a) Sometimes students don't go to school on Monday, but sometimes they do.
b) Whenever there is a Monday, students don't go to school.
Okay, with 1, it COULD mean either one, but my first guess would be a.
But if you move "Every Monday" to the front, you have take it away from the negation.
"They don't go every Monday" is ambiguous. It could mean they never go on Mondays or it could mean some Mondays, but not all.
But "Every Monday, they don't go" you start with the idea that something happens (in this case, doesn't happen) every single Monday. On every Monday, they don't go. On no Mondays do they go.

There is no ambiguity with 2. On Mondays, they don't go. Ever.

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•