angelene001
Member
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2012
- Member Type
- Interested in Language
- Native Language
- Polish
- Home Country
- Poland
- Current Location
- Poland
If the reported sentence is out of date the tenses change.
I've read that the tenses change as follows:
past simple -> past perfect or past simple
past continuous -> past perfect continuous or past continuous
I don't understand when they can stay the same and when they should change.
Is it usually optional to change or not?
Are there situations in which not changing is a mistake?
I've got a sentence:
'I was locking the car when a traffic warden turned up,' she said.
1. She said that she was locking the car when a traffic warden turned up.
2. She said she had been locking the car when a traffic warden turned up.
3. She said she had been locking the car when a traffic warden had turned up.
Are they all correct?
I've also read that in time clauses they don't change. But is changing them in time clauses a mistake?
'The car broke down while I was driving to work,' he said.
Are 1, 2 and 3 correct?
1. He said that the car had broken down while he was driving to work.
2. He said that the car broke down while he was driving to work.
3. He said that the car had broken down while he had been driving to work.
I've read that the tenses change as follows:
past simple -> past perfect or past simple
past continuous -> past perfect continuous or past continuous
I don't understand when they can stay the same and when they should change.
Is it usually optional to change or not?
Are there situations in which not changing is a mistake?
I've got a sentence:
'I was locking the car when a traffic warden turned up,' she said.
1. She said that she was locking the car when a traffic warden turned up.
2. She said she had been locking the car when a traffic warden turned up.
3. She said she had been locking the car when a traffic warden had turned up.
Are they all correct?
I've also read that in time clauses they don't change. But is changing them in time clauses a mistake?
'The car broke down while I was driving to work,' he said.
Are 1, 2 and 3 correct?
1. He said that the car had broken down while he was driving to work.
2. He said that the car broke down while he was driving to work.
3. He said that the car had broken down while he had been driving to work.