englishhobby
Key Member
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2009
- Member Type
- English Teacher
- Native Language
- Russian
- Home Country
- Russian Federation
- Current Location
- Russian Federation
The eternal question about the difference between the present perfect and past simple :
While reading the movie script of "Pride and Prejudice" and comparing it to what the actors actually say in the movie, I noticed that in the movie they changed the phrase said by Caroline Bingley from "Have you walked here?" (in the script) to "Did you walk here?" (in the movie). I think it was done to attract attention to the process of Elizabeth's going to Mr Bingley's house through the mud, not to the result (her dress was dirty).
Still, my question is: how would the meaning have changed had they used the initial phrase with the present perfect?
Here's the extract:
Bingley's house
FOOTMAN
Miss Elizabeth Bennet.
Lizzie comes in, her face flushed, her skirt covered in mud. She looks ravishing. Darcy stares at her, then quickly rises to his feet. Caroline Bingley, astonished, looks her up and down.
CAROLINE BINGLEY
Good Lord, Miss Bennet. Have you walked here?
ELIZABETH
I'm so sorry. How is my sister?
While reading the movie script of "Pride and Prejudice" and comparing it to what the actors actually say in the movie, I noticed that in the movie they changed the phrase said by Caroline Bingley from "Have you walked here?" (in the script) to "Did you walk here?" (in the movie). I think it was done to attract attention to the process of Elizabeth's going to Mr Bingley's house through the mud, not to the result (her dress was dirty).
Still, my question is: how would the meaning have changed had they used the initial phrase with the present perfect?
Here's the extract:
Bingley's house
FOOTMAN
Miss Elizabeth Bennet.
Lizzie comes in, her face flushed, her skirt covered in mud. She looks ravishing. Darcy stares at her, then quickly rises to his feet. Caroline Bingley, astonished, looks her up and down.
CAROLINE BINGLEY
Good Lord, Miss Bennet. Have you walked here?
ELIZABETH
I'm so sorry. How is my sister?
Last edited by a moderator: