Jethro Fraser
New member
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2014
- Member Type
- Other
- Native Language
- English
- Home Country
- South Africa
- Current Location
- South Korea
A rule of concord states that indefinite and distributive pronouns (eg. "someone", "no one", "anyone", "everyone", "any one", "each one" etc.) take the singular form of the verb and agree in number (i.e singular) and person (i.e third person) with their corresponding pronouns/noun equivalents: For example: "Anyone may choose his own brand of clothing", "No one has the right to indulge himself at the expense of another person", "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion", etc.
I have come across sentences like "An expert is someone who is very skilled in what they do", "Can anyone tell me what they dreamt about last night?", "Every one here today has a right to speak their minds". For the last sentence, the 'correction' - in terms of the rule - would be: "... has the right to speak his own mind".
Are we to sacrifice sense and force in the name of liguistic purism?
Please note that in my examples, "his" does the work for "his/her". I have two problems with this: firstly, breaking the rule, especially in the penult and last example, seems more sensible and 'right' given the sense of plurality; secondly, the use of "his/her", especially in complex constructions, will lead to bad style/clumsiness.
Does anyone have any suggestions or comments regarding this?
Jethro
I have come across sentences like "An expert is someone who is very skilled in what they do", "Can anyone tell me what they dreamt about last night?", "Every one here today has a right to speak their minds". For the last sentence, the 'correction' - in terms of the rule - would be: "... has the right to speak his own mind".
Are we to sacrifice sense and force in the name of liguistic purism?
Please note that in my examples, "his" does the work for "his/her". I have two problems with this: firstly, breaking the rule, especially in the penult and last example, seems more sensible and 'right' given the sense of plurality; secondly, the use of "his/her", especially in complex constructions, will lead to bad style/clumsiness.
Does anyone have any suggestions or comments regarding this?
Jethro