They both work. I would probably use "seemed".
Please take a look at this sentence:
I didn't ask you because I thought if I asked her she would probably bring you along anyway since it seems/seemed like you guys are BFF.
Should I use seems or seemed here?
The sentence began past sentence. It should be used past tense for the answer.
I prefer "seemed" here.
Am I wrong, not a teacher.
Both are fine. A comma is needed after "anyway", though.