Alice Chu
Member
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2019
- Member Type
- English Teacher
- Native Language
- Chinese
- Home Country
- Taiwan
- Current Location
- Taiwan
Hello, dear teachers.
Could you please tell me if my understanding is correct? Thank you very much.
1. (A) Lisa will make a cake at three o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will start at three o’clock this afternoon.
1. (B) Lisa will make a cake by three this afternoon.
→The action will start before three o’clock this afternoon.
2. Lisa will be making a cake at four o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will be in progress at four o’clock this afternoon.
We can’t use “by” in place of “at” here.
3. (A) Lisa will have been making a cake for two hours at five o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will have lasted (for) two hours at five o’clock this afternoon, and the action is temporary.
3. (B) Lisa will have been making a cake for two hours by five o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will have lasted (for) two hours until five o’clock this afternoon, and the action is temporary.
4. (A) Lisa will have made a cake at six o’clock this evening.
→The action will be completed at six o’clock this evening.
4. (B) Lisa will have made a cake by six o’clock this evening.
→The action will be completed before six o’clock this evening.
5. (A) I will have worked in the company for 20 years next month.
→The action will have lasted (for) 20 years next month.
5. (A) I will have worked in the company for 20 years by next month.
→The action will have lasted (for) 20 years until next month.
Could you please tell me if my understanding is correct? Thank you very much.
1. (A) Lisa will make a cake at three o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will start at three o’clock this afternoon.
1. (B) Lisa will make a cake by three this afternoon.
→The action will start before three o’clock this afternoon.
2. Lisa will be making a cake at four o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will be in progress at four o’clock this afternoon.
We can’t use “by” in place of “at” here.
3. (A) Lisa will have been making a cake for two hours at five o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will have lasted (for) two hours at five o’clock this afternoon, and the action is temporary.
3. (B) Lisa will have been making a cake for two hours by five o’clock this afternoon.
→The action will have lasted (for) two hours until five o’clock this afternoon, and the action is temporary.
4. (A) Lisa will have made a cake at six o’clock this evening.
→The action will be completed at six o’clock this evening.
4. (B) Lisa will have made a cake by six o’clock this evening.
→The action will be completed before six o’clock this evening.
5. (A) I will have worked in the company for 20 years next month.
→The action will have lasted (for) 20 years next month.
5. (A) I will have worked in the company for 20 years by next month.
→The action will have lasted (for) 20 years until next month.