Are these sentences correct:
1-I like girls who are like Joan: intelligent.
2-I like girls like Joan: intelligent and hard-working.
3-I like girls like Joan: intelligent.
4-Cathy gives a bad name to girls like me: in service.

Academic
Are these sentences correct:
1-I like girls who are like Joan: intelligent.
2-I like girls like Joan: intelligent and hard-working.
3-I like girls like Joan: intelligent.
4-Cathy gives a bad name to girls like me: in service.
I would rephrase 4 as: “Cathy gives a bad name to girls in service like me.”
The other sentences are all correct. However, as the word “like” is used with two different meanings in 1–3, I would suggest 1 as being better than 2 and 3 at avoiding ambiguity.
(:-))
You could also replace 'like' with 'such as' to avoid the repetition. :o
I would not use a colon in that way in formal writing. It is not technically incorrect, but it is strange. In each case, the trailing words can be used as adjectives. I also would not repeat "like". "I prefer/am attracted to intelligent girls like Joan."Originally Posted by navi tasan
Pope of the Dictionary.com Forum