Student or Learner
what do you mean by "on paper the red team should have won", The captain showed a few of his tricks, dribbling and foxing them" and "although the red team forced a goal in the twelfth minute"?
What do you mean by "on paper", "foxing" and "in the twelfth minute"?
A fox is a tricky animal. So in this context, foxing them means that he has many tricky moves when he plays.
I believe "in the twelfth minute" is a soccer term meaning a specific time in the game. When they report an event or goal in the game they mention the minute it occured.