"It's time we went home?" or "It's time we should go home?"

Status
Not open for further replies.

e2e4

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2007
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Serbo-Croatian
Home Country
Bosnia Herzegovina
Current Location
Bosnia Herzegovina
Yeah,

the present subjunctive particle has exactly the same form as the infinitive;therefore the present subjunctive of to be is be for all persons, and the present subjunctive of all other verbs is the same as their present tense except that s isn't added for the third person singular.

The e2e4 comes on here. (present tense)
Long come to e2e4! (subjunctive)

The past subjunctive particle has exactly the same form as the simple past except that with the verb be the past subjunctive form is either I/he/she/it was or I/he/she/it were (to emphasis the unreality), (mostly were is used)

Past subjunctives are often known as unreal pasts.

Use of the present subjunctive

1) mostly to express a wish or hope.
Also, for example
If need be I'll give you a few examples. (be-present subjunctive)

Use of the past subjunctive

1) can be used after as though to emphasis unreality or improbability or a doubt in the present
He talks as though he knew the grammar perfectly

2) can be used in a phrase

It is time + subject + past subjunctive
It is time we went. (we are late),(now, present again)

There is similar expression It is time to go

but the meaning isn't the same. I already explained about in some of my last posts.

In addition,
concerning some grammatical mistakes in my sentences I already explained that I do not care about at this level.
I always focus on the matter we are talking about.

Under this topic we were discussing the phrase It's time we went home and not complex infinitives or perfect conditional.

But by the way you might tell me :-D which of these forms are complex infinitives:

A) to have read, to have found, etc
B) to have been talking, to have been sleeping etc..
C) He is hoping to be thanked
D) I was hoping to have been thanked but for that I am dissapointed.


Finally I already said
I might have used
There was no any other reason for you to go home. instead of
There was no any other reason for you to (((should))) have gone home. (should shouldn't have been there), (to have gone is a very complex infinitive actually perfect infinitive)
And I also explained what had pulled me to say that way.

Simple infinitive to go could be good enough because the auxiliary was in the sentence point to the past very well.
 

e2e4

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2007
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Serbo-Croatian
Home Country
Bosnia Herzegovina
Current Location
Bosnia Herzegovina
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

Just to add what came on my mind.
@Clark
Maybe you've mixed all of this with the unreal conditionals in the past.

I would have got a seat in the train if I had come in time.
I could have helped if I had been there.

Sorry for dropping in.
Anyway I'll be off on here in the next few days.
see ya,
see ye

Cheerio. Have a good time.
 
Last edited:

Clark

Key Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

e2e4,

1. You refer to subjunctive forms as 'particles'. It's the first time that I've heard a verb form being called 'particle'. Is it a neologism of your own?

2. If you label a subjunctive form identical to the past simple tense as past subjunctive (e.g. He talked as though he knew her), what name do you use for a subjunctive form that indicates a prior action?
e.g. He talked as though he had seen her before.

3. Now I understand that by 'very complex infinitive' you mean an analytical form called a perfect or a passive infinitive. Your 'very creative approach' to using grammatical terms sometimes prevents me from understanding your writings.

4. No, I haven't 'mixed up anything with unreal conditionals'. The fact is that the same subjunctive forms are used in sentences with unreal condition.

e.g. If I knew her I would talk to her.
If I had known her I would have talked to her.

'Knew' and 'had known' are subjunctive forms - present subjunctive and past subjunctive, respectively.

5. It's a pity you have to leave. I will certainly miss your wonderful prose. Enjoy your trip.:-D
 

riverkid

Key Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2006
Member Type
English Teacher
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

e2e4,

2. If you label a subjunctive form identical to the past simple tense as past subjunctive (e.g. He talked as though he knew her), what name do you use for a subjunctive form that indicates a prior action?
e.g. He talked as though he had seen her before.


4. No, I haven't 'mixed up anything with unreal conditionals'. The fact is that the same subjunctive forms are used in sentences with unreal condition.

e.g. If I knew her I would talk to her.
If I had known her I would have talked to her.

'Knew' and 'had known' are subjunctive forms - present subjunctive and past subjunctive, respectively.

Hello Clark and E2e4.

The subjunctive, as a form, is almost extinct in English. There are only a couple of forms left.

The examples in 2, above, which I've put in red are not examples of subjunctive forms. They are backshifts to illustrate reported speech.

In 4, which I've blued, in the example sentences,

If I knew her I would talk to her.

If I had known her I would have talked to her.


'knew' and 'had known' are not subjunctive forms.

§ 61. subjunctive

...

English has had a subjunctive mood since Old English times, but most of the functions of the old subjunctive have been taken over by auxiliary verbs like may and should, and the subjunctive survives only in very limited situations.

It has a present and past form. The present form is identical to the base form of the verb, so you only notice it in the third person singular, which has no final -s, and in the case of the verb be, which has the form be instead of am, is, and are. The past subjunctive is identical with the past tense except in the case of the verb be, which uses were for all persons: If I were rich …, If he were rich …, If they were rich….

§ 61. subjunctive. 1. Grammar. The American Heritage Book of English Usage. 1996

There has been, and still is, much disagreement over this and other forms/collocations in English. What's important to ESLs is that they understand how to use these different forms. It's not important that they learn about these different forms.

Students that get hung up on the subjunctive often miss all the other ways we have to say the same things;

If he were to go there, ...

If he was to go there, ...

Imagine that we go there, ...

Let's say that we go there, ...

Say that we go there, ...
 

henz988

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2008
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

As far as I know, It’s time we go is also acceptable, but there may be a BE/AE difference in usage. If you're writing for an exam, avoid "It's time we go."

As above mentioned, It’s time we should go is definitely wrong.

 

tzfujimino

Key Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Japanese
Home Country
Japan
Current Location
Japan
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

As far as I know, It’s time we go is also acceptable, but there may be a BE/AE difference in usage. If you're writing for an exam, avoid "It's time we go."

As above mentioned, It’s time we should go is definitely wrong.

Hi, henz988!:-D:-D
Why is it that "It's time we should go" is definitely wrong?:?:
 

henz988

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2008
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

An American friend told me so. :lol:
 

tzfujimino

Key Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Japanese
Home Country
Japan
Current Location
Japan
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

An American friend told me so. :lol:

I see!:-D:-D
So.."It's time we go." is commonly used in America.:-D
Then...I wonder why "It's time we should go." is unacceptable....
Thank you so much, henz988!:-D
 

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

Hi, henz988!:-D:-D
Why is it that "It's time we should go" is definitely wrong?:?:
After a whole day of hard work I'm very tired. It's time [that] we _____ home.

A) go :tick: <see note below>
B) shall :cross:
C) went :tick: traditional
D) should go :tick: colloquial

It's time we left means in effect the time has come when we should leave, which is why you'll hear some speakers use the non-traditional form, D) 'should go'.


__________________________
Note,

"It's time we go home"
<a plan to do something, a "real" condition for a future action.>

"It's time we went home"
<a regret that we haven't done something, more focus on the past non-action, and a wishful thought about the future action that may or may not take place—an "unreal" (or unsure) condition for a future action.>

See Grammar Logs for Sunday, December 9, 2001.
 

riverkid

Key Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2006
Member Type
English Teacher
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

After a whole day of hard work I'm very tired. It's time [that] we _____ home.

A) go :tick: <see note below>
B) shall :cross:
C) went :tick: traditional
D) should go :tick: colloquial

It's time we left means in effect the time has come when we should leave, which is why you'll hear some speakers use the non-traditional form, D) 'should go'.

What does 'traditional' mean, Soup?

__________________________
Note,

"It's time we go home"
<a plan to do something, a "real" condition for a future action.>

"It's time we went home"
<a regret that we haven't done something, more focus on the past non-action, and a wishful thought about the future action that may or may not take place—an "unreal" (or unsure) condition for a future action.>

See Grammar Logs for Sunday, December 9, 2001.

I warned Casiopeia [sp?] about this website a couple of years ago. Evidently, she didn't get around to telling you about it. You would think that she would have done so seeing as you two share so many similarities. It's almost as if you two were sisters/brothers/twins.

Although their advice in this case seems to be pretty good their grammar site is riddled with errors, so, overall, I don't think that it's a great idea to be sending ESLs there.
 

Clark

Key Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

Hi Riverkid,

As is known, in the older periods English used to be a synthetic language, and its subjunctive forms were built up synthetically, by means of inflections. If you are talking about those forms, I agree with you - they are 'almost extinct in English.' But the fact is that the place of the old subjunctive forms has been taken by analytical forms in present-day English. They serve the same purpose - they represent an action as hypothetical, and you can hardly include them in the same group together with the indicative mood forms.
e.g. If I had known her better, I wouldn't have talked to her.
Isn't 'had known' an unreal action here? So why do you object to labelling it as subjunctive? If it is not subjunctive then which mood is it?

By the way, referring to some questionable definitions taken from sources full of dogmas can hardly be regarded as a convincing argument in a scientific discussion.

As for your reasoning on what ESL students should or should not learn, I am leaving it without any comment as it is irrelevant to the subject in question.

Rgds
.......
 

rj1948

Senior Member
Joined
May 2, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Tamil
Home Country
India
Current Location
India
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

It's time we went home.Many interpretations and discussions on this sentence but no clarity.
It is simple present tense.A parent may say to a child,"It's time you went to bed"which means,"I want you to go to bed."
If a person looks at his watch and says,"It's time I went" he means he wants to go.It is as simple as that.I'm clear it's not subjunctive form of the verb that indicates imaginary situations.
Regards,
rj1948.
 

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

It's time we went home. /.../ It is simple present tense.
Yes, and no.
“It is time we went home” is the correct sentence. After the expression “It's time”, “would rather” and “wish”, followed by a subject, we can use the past tense with present or future meanings.

Is ‘sky juice’ right?
 

Clark

Key Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

It's time we went home.Many interpretations and discussions on this sentence but no clarity.
It is simple present tense.A parent may say to a child,"It's time you went to bed"which means,"I want you to go to bed."
If a person looks at his watch and says,"It's time I went" he means he wants to go.It is as simple as that.I'm clear it's not subjunctive form of the verb that indicates imaginary situations.
Regards,
rj1948.

The fact that an action refers to the present does not necessarily mean that it is expressed by the simple present tense. By the way, 'went' is not the present but the past form of 'go'. As for your interpretation 'I want you to go to bed' which you give as a proof of the indicative mood form, here is an alternative variant:
You would do the right thing if you went to bed now.
where 'went' is the present subjunctive form of the the verb 'go'.
 

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

You would do the right thing if you went to bed now.
where 'went' is the present subjunctive form of the the verb 'go'.

... if you were to go = if you went :tick:
 

Clark

Key Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

... if you were to go = if you went :tick:

Yes, indeed. This form of the modal 'to be' has a definite future reference in conditional sentences and helps to avoid ambiguity.
 

rj1948

Senior Member
Joined
May 2, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Tamil
Home Country
India
Current Location
India
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

Yes, and no.
“It is time we went home” is the correct sentence. After the expression “It's time”, “would rather” and “wish”, followed by a subject, we can use the past tense with present or future meanings.

Is ‘sky juice’ right?

Many a times,I wondered at your resourcefulness.Still I do.But I never expected that you would quote an obscure site to prove your point.In one of my previous posts,I have given a few sites.Have you seen those?I think there is difference between 'It's time we went ' and 'It's time we should go'
Kindly see:http://answers.yahoo.com/questions/index.qid=20080128061335AAAZZYZ
Answers.com - Online Dictionary, Encyclopedia and much more
BBC Learning English | Home page
Regards,
rj1948.
 
Last edited:

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

I think there is difference between 'It's time we went ' and 'It's time we should go'
Kindly see:http://answers.yahoo.com/questions/index.qid=20080128061335AAAZZYZ
Answers.com - Online Dictionary, Encyclopedia and much more
BBC Learning English | Home page
Regards,
rj1948.
Thank you, but I would rather spend my time here learning about what you think. What is your opinion, and why? Sources are not the be all and end all of truth. There is no such thing as the truth. It is argument that makes it so. ;-) Argue your case, please.
 

rj1948

Senior Member
Joined
May 2, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Tamil
Home Country
India
Current Location
India
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

Thank you, but I would rather spend my time here learning about what you think. What is your opinion, and why? Sources are not the be all and end all of truth. There is no such thing as the truth. It is argument that makes it so. ;-) Argue your case, please.

I'm not now in to enter into an arguement.I had better leave it as it is.
Regards,
rj1948.:cool:
 

Soup

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2007
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
Canada
Current Location
China
Re: It's time we went home? or,It's time we should go home?

I'm not now in to enter into an arguement.I had better leave it as it is.
Regards,
rj1948.:cool:
Please consult your dictionary. Argument has more than one meaning:
2. a discussion involving differing points of view; debate:
They were deeply involved in an argument about inflation.

3. a process of reasoning; series of reasons:
I couldn't follow his argument.

4. a statement, reason, or fact for or against a point:
This is a strong argument in favor of her theory.

5. an address or composition intended to convince or persuade; persuasive discourse. :tick:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top