adverb II

[Anonymous]

1-Last year, the second time I saw him, he was depressed.
2-Last year, the second time I saw him he was depressed.

In which case:
A-The second time I met ever him was last year.
B-I am talking about the second meeting between us that took place last year (I might have met him before last year).

 

[MikeNewYork]

1-Last year, the second time I saw him, he was depressed.
2-Last year, the second time I saw him he was depressed.

In which case:
A-The second time I met ever him was last year.
B-I am talking about the second meeting between us that took place last year (I might have met him before last year).

#1 is A. Because the phrase is set off by commas, it is merely additonal information. It is used to add information to "last year". Therefore, the second time ever was last year.

#2 is not clear. If one intends to talk about the second meeting last year, one would say: The second time I saw him last year, he was depressed.

:wink: