Apositive nouns

[treepixie]

Are commas required for setting these nouns apart?

It was with profound love that my dear birth mother Frances Stevens gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

or

it was with profound love that my dear birth mother, Frances Stevens, gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

Thanks!

 

[treepixie]

comma

Does no one know the answer to this question or should I be posting it in a different category?

Are commas required for setting these nouns apart?

It was with profound love that my dear birth mother Frances Stevens gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

or

it was with profound love that my dear birth mother, Frances Stevens, gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

Thanks!

 

[blacknomi]

Yes, you need commas.

No, it's good to post your questions here. Keep your post alive if no one gets some time to answer it. :lol:

 

[gonghai]

Are commas required for setting these nouns apart?

It was with profound love that my dear birth mother Frances Stevens gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

or

it was with profound love that my dear birth mother, Frances Stevens, gave her blessing for me to be adopted.

Thanks!

YES but i don't think you need the comma before gave

the comma shows that there are only one birth mother

 

[Tdol]

I'd put both in. ;-)

 

[123navE]

Isn't it as simple as it being non-essential, so it needs commas? That's how I learned it I believe.

 

[Maiwand]

Yes, commas are used along with apositive nouns. I am holding the proof of this in from the one of the indian books by the name of English grammar and composition

 

[Kondorosi]

Yes, commas are used along with apositive nouns.

sweeping generalisation

 

[Raymott]

YES but i don't think you need the comma before gave

the comma shows that there are only one birth mother

You can't use one comma in this situation. You need to use either two (my preference) or none.

 

[mlabbe]

It was with profound love that my dear birth mother Frances Stevens gave her blessing for me to be adopted.


DO NOT use commas as one's birth mother is the only birth mother one has. If the modifier precedes the word, and is linked to the word, commas are not necessary. The modifier is not interrupting the sentence and is part of the construction of birth mother Frances Stevens

If the modifier (appositive) follows the mothers name, then it would be set off by commas, eg, "Frances Stevens, my dear birth mother, gave me her blessing."

Use commas when it is a description could be applied to more one person, eg, "I met an author, Frances Drake, at the reception."

Cheers!