Commas, And

Status
Not open for further replies.

ahmadizat

Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Arabic
Home Country
Jordan
Current Location
Jordan
Consider the following:

he is the powerful, smart, agile athlete and great philosopher that we all look up to.

My question is:

A:

1-Does powerful and smart apply to (describe) both agile athlete and great philosopher ?

2-Or, Does powerful and smart apply to (describe) agile athlete only, and hence, great philosopher is another additional issue.

3-Or, do we consider each one separately:

He is the powerful + He is the smart + He is the agile athlete + He is the great philosopher

B:

"that we all look up to" refers to:

-the: great philosopher
-the: agile athlete and great philosopher
-the: powerful and smart and agile athlete and great philosopher


Thanks for reading.
 

David L.

VIP Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Member Type
Other
he is the powerful, smart, agile athlete and great philosopher that we all look up to.

My question is:

2-Or, Does powerful and smart apply to (describe) agile athlete only, and hence, great philosopher is another additional issue. YES
It is the same as,
He is the powerful, smart, agile athlete we all look up to.
He is the great philosopher that we all look up to.

B:

"that we all look up to" refers to:

-the: great philosopher
-the: agile athlete and great philosopher
-the: powerful and smart and agile athlete and great philosopher YES
We look up to this man who is both a powerful, smart, agile athlete and a great philosopher.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top