Confused about agreement of subject and verb.

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
One more question, please.


I have this sentence to ask you, "I" is the subject of the sentence while "who" is the relative pronounce of "I", the question is that "who" should be used with "is" or not or should it be "am" or somethingelse?

"As I am herein, in the status of being brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree, who is a younger sister of my wife."


Thank you and best regards,
Piak
 

MikeNewYork

VIP Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
Piak-v said:
One more question, please.


I have this sentence to ask you, "I" is the subject of the sentence while "who" is the relative pronounce of "I", the question is that "who" should be used with "is" or not or should it be "am" or somethingelse?

"As I am herein, in the status of being brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree, who is a younger sister of my wife."

First of all, it is not a sentence. It is two clauses, one beginning with the
subordinating conjunction "as" and the other beginning with "who". Second, in this case "who" is referring to Miss Mayuree, not to "I". One can deduce that from the language. The speaker cannot be the younger sister of his wife.

Had the relative pronoun "who" been referring to "I", there would be a difference of opinion about the verb form that should follow "who". Some grammarians argue that "who" should reflect the number and person of its antecedent, and would choose "who am". Others argue that "who" is always third person and should only reflect the number of the antecedent. This group would choose "who is".

Thank you and best regards,
Piak
 

Piak

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2003
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Thai
Home Country
Thailand
Current Location
Thailand
Thank you again Mike New York for your clarification of this cunfusion about the agreement of subject and verb. Would you mind correcting it for me? How would you say it in the real English, please?

The event is that I as referred in the letter of certification or power of attorney, an d I am as the brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree who is a younger sister of my wife, and I was authorized by Miss. Mayuree to do something for her " ("As I am herein, in the status of being , who is a younger sister of my wife." )

Thank you and best regards,
Piak-v (Piak because there was some error happened while I was posting the question, the system need me to enter new user 's name)
 

Piak

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2003
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Thai
Home Country
Thailand
Current Location
Thailand
Thank you again Mike New York for your clarification of this cunfusion about the agreement of subject and verb. Would you mind correcting it for me? How would you say it in the real English, please?

The event is that I as referred in the letter of certification or power of attorney, an d I am as the brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree who is a younger sister of my wife, and I was authorized by Miss. Mayuree to do something for her " ("As I am herein, in the status of being , who is a younger sister of my wife." )

Thank you and best regards,
Piak-v (Piak because there was an error happened while I was posting the question, the system needed me to enter new user 's name)
 

Tdol

Editor, UsingEnglish.com
Staff member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
UK
Current Location
Japan
You could just write 'Miss Mayuree, my wife's younger sister,'. This way, you'd avoid the 'who' altogether.;-)
 

MikeNewYork

VIP Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
Piak said:
Thank you again Mike New York for your clarification of this cunfusion about the agreement of subject and verb. Would you mind correcting it for me? How would you say it in the real English, please?

The event is that I as referred in the letter of certification or power of attorney, an d I am as the brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree who is a younger sister of my wife, and I was authorized by Miss. Mayuree to do something for her " ("As I am herein, in the status of being , who is a younger sister of my wife." )

Thank you and best regards,
Piak-v (Piak because there was an error happened while I was posting the question, the system needed me to enter new user 's name)

"As I am herein, in the status of being brother-in-law of Miss. Mayuree, who is a younger sister of my wife."

Legalize can be a bit trying, but this is realtively clear.

This says:

I am the brother-in-law of Miss Mayuree, the younger sister of my wife (and hold power-of-attorney for her).

:wink:
 

Piak

Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2003
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Thai
Home Country
Thailand
Current Location
Thailand
Thank you again TDOl & Mike New York for the second response
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top