Correct Grammar

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
Bush's Agenda pamphlet is entitled....... "A PLan For A Safer World And More Hopeful America" IS it correct to say "more" with hopeful. I was told you can only be hopeful, not more hopeful.

Thank you
GM
 

Mister Micawber

Key Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
Japan
I can be more or less hopeful about many things, gmdad. I don't believe that I've seen 'hopeful' in a list of real absolutes like 'unique, absolute, dead, genuine'.

Here is Wikipedia's take on the problem:

'A perennial issue in English usage involves the comparison of so called "absolute" adjectives, the use of terms of comparison with words that in logic are not thought to admit of comparison. There are, of course, many adjectives that admit of no comparison, chiefly because the qualities they name are either present or absent; nothing is *more Cretaceous or *more igneous. The issue arises with words such as 'perfect', which according to the prescriptivists is another quality that does not admit of comparison; either something is perfect or it is not. Since true perfection is unachievable in the sublunary sphere, people like the drafters of the Constitution of the United States are constantly saying things like 'form a more perfect union'; what they mean, of course, is 'more nearly perfect', and this is what the usage prescriptivists think they should have written. Since good writers and important leaders have used the contested form, the prescriptivists are bucking a well established usage here; in practice, the contested form is understood without error.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top