lagoo
Member
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2017
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Chinese
- Home Country
- China
- Current Location
- China
Hi,
Here are two sentences:
(1) The man, having lived in Paris for years, decided to return to London.
(2) The man having lived in Paris for years decided to return to London.
My English teacher said (1) is correct while (2) is wrong. But he didn't explain the reason, or he might not know either.
Whithout reason, just remembering the rules seems a bit silly way to learn English.
Could you help me clarify it?
Here are two sentences:
(1) The man, having lived in Paris for years, decided to return to London.
(2) The man having lived in Paris for years decided to return to London.
My English teacher said (1) is correct while (2) is wrong. But he didn't explain the reason, or he might not know either.
Whithout reason, just remembering the rules seems a bit silly way to learn English.
Could you help me clarify it?