Is this sentence grammatically correct?

Status
Not open for further replies.

verso

Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Member Type
Student or Learner
Hello everyone! I am studying at the university to become an English teacher, and I should know the answer to this, but here it is:

"I am all that you have home." (If anyone here is a fan of The Decemberists, then they might recognize this line!)

"I" would be noun phrase one and the subject
"am" would be the predicating verb and stative verb
"all that you have home" would be the subject complement and second noun phrase, where "all" is the quantifying predeterminer, "that" is the demonstrative determiner, "you" is the head-noun, and then... what would "have home" be? I am so embarrassed! I am not entirely sure whether or not everything I have above is correct (so please, be sure to let me know if it isn't!) :oops:
 
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Member Type
Academic
"I am all that you have home."

It seems your analysis is correct to some extent:

I= Pronoun functioning as a Subject
am= linking verb functioning of course as a Main Verb
all that you have home= Nominal clause functioning as a Subject Complement

I believe that the relationship between "all" and "that you have home" is (=) In other words

"all" is equal in meaning to "that you have home"

If my assumption is correct, then "all" is a noun

and

"that you have at home" is an Appositive Clause

This appositive clause is analysed as follows:

You= Pronoun functioning as a Subject
have= Main Verb
at home= a prepositional phrase functioning as an Adverbial (of place)
 

verso

Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Member Type
Student or Learner
I have actually considered the possibility of "all" functioning as a noun, but I wasn't entirely sure whether or not appositive clauses could begin with demonstrative pronouns. Is the appositive clause, "all that you have home" (renaming the subject)? And is it possible for an appositive clause to come after a linking, stative verb? I suppose so! Yes, actually, that does seem to make sense. So "all that you have home" is an appositive clause, renaming the subject?
 
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Member Type
Academic
"That" here, I think, is not a demonstrative pronoun.

That girl is my daughter. (Here, it is a demonstrative pronoun)

That he is happier is obvious. ("That" here is appositive as the original sentence is: The fact that he is happier is obvious)

all that you have at home" is an appositive clause, renaming the subject?

I would say that
All = Noun
and

"that you have at home" is the Appositive clause. It modifies, so to speak, the noun "all".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top