G

#### gary1

##### Guest

^ = the square root

^5 + y = a rational number (ie a number which can be written as a/b)

can anybody find a value for y?

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Status
- Not open for further replies.

G

^ = the square root

^5 + y = a rational number (ie a number which can be written as a/b)

can anybody find a value for y?

- Joined
- Nov 13, 2002

- Member Type
- Academic

- Native Language
- American English

- Home Country
- United States

- Current Location
- United States

gary1 said:

^ = the square root

^5 + y = a rational number (ie a number which can be written as a/b)

can anybody find a value for y?

I'm not sure what you are asking. The value of "y" could be just about anything.

A

an irrational number. So the only way y is rational is that a is equal to b or an his multiple. for example ^5 or 2*^5

- Joined
- Nov 13, 2002

- Member Type
- Academic

- Native Language
- American English

- Home Country
- United States

- Current Location
- United States

artax said:

an irrational number. So the only way y is rational is that a is equal to b or an his multiple. for example ^5 or 2*^5

Erm...OK. :wink:

- Joined
- Nov 13, 2002

- Member Type
- Academic

- Native Language
- American English

- Home Country
- United States

- Current Location
- United States

tdol said:I was going to say that. <liar> :lol:

:multi:

H

You are correct! She/he is a liar!

One cannot solve an equation with two unknowns!

e.g. a + b = 10

if a is equal one, b will be equal to nine,

However, if a is equal to two, b will be equal to eight and so on.

In conclusion, a and b are variables.

- Joined
- Feb 9, 2003

- Member Type
- Other

- Native Language
- American English

- Home Country
- United States

- Current Location
- United States

Hong Kong Chinese said:

You are correct! She/he is a liar!

One cannot solve an equation with two unknowns!

e.g. a + b = 10

if a is equal one, b will be equal to nine,

However, if a is equal to two, b will be equal to eight and so on.

In conclusion, a and b are variables.

I believe you are right, but I think Tdol was joking by calling himself a liar when he said, "I was going to say that."

:wink:

- Joined
- Nov 13, 2002

- Member Type

- Native Language
- British English

- Home Country
- UK

- Current Location
- Japan

Hong Kong Chinese said:

You are correct! She/he is a liar!

One cannot solve an equation with two unknowns!

e.g. a + b = 10

if a is equal one, b will be equal to nine,

However, if a is equal to two, b will be equal to eight and so on.

In conclusion, a and b are variables.

Thanks for that, but I was calling myself a liar. If I was right, it was only by accident. If I disagreed with someone's view on the forum,I would try to phrase it more diplomatically. ;-)

- Joined
- Nov 13, 2002

- Member Type
- Academic

- Native Language
- American English

- Home Country
- United States

- Current Location
- United States

tdol said:Thanks for that, but I was calling myself a liar. If I was right, it was only by accident. If I disagreed with someone's view on the forum,I would try to phrase it more diplomatically. ;-)

I can attest to that fact. :wink:

Hong Kong Chinese said:

You are correct! She/he is a liar!

One cannot solve an equation with two unknowns!

e.g. a + b = 10

if a is equal one, b will be equal to nine,

However, if a is equal to two, b will be equal to eight and so on.

In conclusion, a and b are variables.

artax is correct.

artax said:Summing a rational number to an irrational oneyou always obtain an irrational number. So the only way y is rational is that a (of a/b, 'a' over 'b') is equal to b or an his multiple. for example ^5 or 2*^5

H

I think that I have misunderstood the first reply of Teacher Tdol, which may probably be caused by our culture difference.

Though I almost forgot all the algebra formulas, as a rule, I still insist that:

One unknown in one equation

Two unknowns in two equations

Three unknowns in three equations

Those unknowns can be solved!

I normally don’t call myself a liar, but sometimes an imbecile.

- Status
- Not open for further replies.