Noncount

Status
Not open for further replies.

kooiu

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Yoruba
Home Country
Nigeria
Current Location
United States
Please do these three statements mean the same thing when using non-counts (chanage, revision) in a general sense:

1. Change in political conditions creates opportunities for revision in political rules.

2. A change in political conditions creates opportunities for a revision in political rules.

3. Changes in political conditions creates opportunities for revisions in political rules.


I do not know why "Theory" is noncount. What is the difference between "economic theory" and "an economic theory" or "economic theories"? Does "economic theories" imply a general way of referring to economic theory in much the way as the "lion", "lions", or "a lion" are generally used?
 
Last edited:

susiedqq

Key Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
1. Change in political conditions creates opportunities for revision in political rules.

Change / creates / opportunities / for revision

2. A change in political conditions creates opportunities for a revision in political rules.

A change / creates / an opportunity / for revision

3. Changes in political conditions creates opportunities for revisions in political rules.

Changes / create / opportunities / for revisions


Theory is a very abstract subject, like science. One usually discusses one theory, the theory, a theory, not many theories.
 

kooiu

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Yoruba
Home Country
Nigeria
Current Location
United States
Thank you susiedqq for your help.

I however do not have any problem with your restatements of my sentences.

I was asking if the three statements mean the same thing given that the statements seem general and that "change" and "revision" are uncountable nouns. The second and third statements will be clear to me if they are about specific instances of change and revision that actually occur- we had a change of mind about the issue yesterday, or we understook a revision of our paper yesterday.

My question: Are the following statements general statements and why?

1. Change in political conditions creates opportunities for revision in political rules.

2. A change in political conditions creates opportunities for a revision in political rules.

3. Changes in political conditions creates opportunities for revisions in political rules.


Theory: I have come across references to "economic theories", "an economic theory", "economic theory" in the same article. Since "theory" is abstract, why not just economic theory? Or does "economic theory" mean "economic science" while "economic theories" and "an economic theory" may not make sense?

My main concern here is when an uncountable noun (an abstract noun) may be used like a countable noun (or countable nouns) in a general sense without implying specific instances as in these two general statements about the countable noun "muscian":
"Muscians must work hard for success"
"A muscian must work hard for success"
 

susiedqq

Key Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
I am not sure what you want to know but when I see these two sentences I think:

(all, many, some, few, global category) "Musicians must work hard for success"

(one who has chosen this career in music) "A musician must work hard for success"
 

Anglika

No Longer With Us
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Member Type
Other
Theory: I have come across references to "economic theories", "an economic theory", "economic theory" in the same article. Since "theory" is abstract, why not just economic theory? Or does "economic theory" mean "economic science" while "economic theories" and "an economic theory" may not make sense?

Without context - the article may be discussing economic theories in principle and practice. The author needs to refer to the multiple theories [economic theories], specific theory [an economic theory] or economic theory in general [economic theory].

My main concern here is when an uncountable noun (an abstract noun) may be used like a countable noun (or countable nouns) in a general sense without implying specific instances as in these two general statements about the countable noun "musician":
"Musicians must work hard for success"
"A musician must work hard for success"


Abstract nouns are not necessarily uncountable. Theory has a plural - theories.

.
 

kooiu

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Yoruba
Home Country
Nigeria
Current Location
United States
Thank you, susiedqq and Anglika. Very grateful for your help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top