two objects

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
Dear teacher

I'd like to ask about passive sentences.
In the exercise we change some active sentences to passive sentences.
If a sentence have two objects, two sentences can be made. However, are both sentences natural to native speakers? Or is one of them too awkward?

For example: I changed 1) to 2) and 3)
1) My uncle gave me a nice watch.
2) I was given a nice watch by my uncle.
3) A nice watch was given me by my uncle.

Do 2) and 3) sound natural?

Thank you.
 

Casiopea

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Member Type
Other
Lina said:
Dear teacher

I'd like to ask about passive sentences.
In the exercise we change some active sentences to passive sentences.
If a sentence have two objects, two sentences can be made. However, are both sentences natural to native speakers? Or is one of them too awkward?

For example: I changed 1) to 2) and 3)
1) My uncle gave me a nice watch.
2) I was given a nice watch by my uncle.
3) A nice watch was given me by my uncle.

Do 2) and 3) sound natural?

Thank you.

The 'by' phrase sounds odd because it emphasizes the agent, the doer of the action. With the passive, the object, not the subject is emphasized:

Active: My uncle gave me a watch. (Indirect Object)
Passive: I was given a watch. (OK)

Active: My uncle gave a watch to me. (Indirect Object)
Passive: A watch was given to me. (OK)

All the best, :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top