Was doing and do

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
Dear teather:
I'm a Chinese girl. Now I have a question to answer you, please write back to me. Thank you very much
(1).The class was holding a meeting last Wednesday afternoon.
(2).The class held a meeting last Wednesday afternoon.
Which of the two questions is correct? Why?
Please answer the question for me. Thank you very much again! :wink:
 
J

jack_yond

Guest
both are right , aren't they ,teacher?
ps:i'm also a beginner ,hhoho
 

Casiopea

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Member Type
Other
K.Margaret said:
Dear teather:
I'm a Chinese girl. Now I have a question to answer you, please write back to me. Thank you very much
(1).The class was holding a meeting last Wednesday afternoon.
(2).The class held a meeting last Wednesday afternoon.
Which of the two questions is correct? Why?
Please answer the question for me. Thank you very much again! :wink:

That's right. :D Both are correct. The difference between 'was holding' and 'held' has to do with continuity. 'was holding' expresses a state of on going, like this,

The class was holding a meeting last Wednesday afternoon when the fire alarm went off. (i.e., while we were meeting, the alarm sounded) Both the meeting and the alarm happened during the same time.

All the best,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top