was or were

Status
Not open for further replies.
U

Unregistered

Guest
Which of the following is correct?

If your aunt dies when you are young, you will probably wish you had known her. If that aunt WAS your godmother, you'll miss her presence at religion events.

OR

If your aunt dies when you are young, you will probably wish you had known her. If that aunt WERE your godmother, you'll miss her presence at religion events.

Thank you!
 
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Member Type
Academic
If that aunt WERE your godmother, you'll miss her presence at religion events.

Basically, you say "If that aunt were..."

I have a feeling however that something is wrong with the grammar of the sentence. This would make me ask mysefl: can I make a future speculation and use the past at the same time? I am not sure.
 

Anglika

No Longer With Us
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Member Type
Other
Since your aunt is dead, it ought to be "If she had been".

If she was absent but still living, then "was" would be correct.
 

riverkid

Banned
Joined
Aug 17, 2006
Member Type
English Teacher
Since your aunt is dead, it ought to be "If she had been".

If she was absent but still living, then "was" would be correct.


Anglika,

I'm puzzled.

Could this not be a generic conditional, as opposed to a fact-counterfact situation where there's no actual aunt. Once the first condition is set, that this theoretical aunt dies when you're young, the question then isn't if she had been your godmother but whether she was.

Whether she "had been your aunt" would only apply to an actual fact-counterfact situation, would it not?

If it's a theoretical aunt, a theoretical condition, then it would have nothing to do with her being alive or dead, right?

ORIGINAL:
If your aunt dies when you are young, you will probably wish you had known her. If that aunt WAS your godmother, you'll miss her presence at religion events.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top