What is the difference?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Deepurple

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Hong Kong
Current Location
Hong Kong
"If you are a citizen who was absent from Mainland China during (your), (the), (his/her) specified call up period under the so-and-so exercise (i.e. a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 and who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007), you should..."

Which determiner is more appropriate in the above sentence? And why?
Thank you.
 

Anglika

No Longer With Us
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Member Type
Other
"If you are a citizen who was absent from Mainland China during (your), (the), (his/her) specified call up period under the so-and-so exercise (i.e. a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 and who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007), you should..."

Which determiner is more appropriate in the above sentence? And why?
Thank you.


The answer is in the sentence - look at the logic.
 

Deepurple

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2007
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Hong Kong
Current Location
Hong Kong
"If you are a citizen who was absent from Mainland China during (your), (the), (his/her) specified call up period under the so-and-so exercise (i.e. a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 and who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007), you should..."

The answer is in the sentence - look at the logic.

But how about we split the sentence into two as follows:

(i) If you are a citizen (who)
(ii) A citizen (one of the citizens) who was absent from Mainland China during (his/her) or ("the" -since the date is defined in the brackets as "a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 and who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007".) specified call up period under the ...

Such as it may be, was it more logical to use (his/her) or (the) rather than "your" in the above sentence?
 

Anglika

No Longer With Us
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Member Type
Other
But how about we split the sentence into two as follows:

(i) If you are a citizen (who)
(ii) A citizen (one of the citizens) who was absent from Mainland China during (his/her) or ("the" -since the date is defined in the brackets as "a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 and who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007".) specified call up period under the ...

Such as it may be, was it more logical to use (his/her) or (the) rather than "your" in the above sentence?

I do not see that you can split the sentence in this way. As it is, it is addressed to "you" and logic requires the pronouns to be connected.

The entire thing can be rewritten to be abstract and therefore avoid pronouns:

"Any citizen who was absent from Mainland China during (the) specified call up period under the so-and-so exercise (i.e. a holder of a Chinese ID card issued before 05 March 2006 who was born in or before 1967, in 1980 - 1995, or in 1999 - 2007), should..."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top