Which One Is Correct?

[Cervantes]

Which one of the following is correct? Are they both correct?

1- "Her voice sounds as if inmersed in water"

2- "Her voice sounds as if she were inmersed in water"


Thanks

 

[2006]

Which one of the following is correct? Are they both correct?

1- "Her voice sounds as if inmersed in water" :cross:

2- "Her voice sounds as if she were immersed in water. :tick:

Her voice can't be immersed in water, but she could be immersed in water.

Thanks

2006