with

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Anonymous

Guest
Which of the following is correct:

1-With Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
2-Alongside Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
3-Alongisde with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
4-Along with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.


Do these sentences imply that Quantum Mechanics had only the four founding fathers who have been mentioned here or could it have other founding fathers?
 

navi tasan

Key Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
Armenian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
United States
This one was me. I thought I was logged in. This isn't the first time this is happening. I don't mind being written down as a guest though, so normally I just let it be. I saw that Makaveli had come back to identify himself, so I thought I should do the same. Can't be more macchiavellic than Macchiavelli, like you can't be more Catholic than the Pope!! :wink:
 

RonBee

Moderator
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Member Type
Other
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
navi tasan said:
1-With Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
2-Alongside Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
3-Alongisde with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
4-Along with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.


Do these sentences imply that Quantum Mechanics had only the four founding fathers who have been mentioned here or could it have other founding fathers?

The sentences say that those men were four of the founders of quantum mechanics, but it doesn't exclude the possibility of significant contributions from others. What it says to me is that each one of them was one of the founding fathers of quantum mechanics. The writer might consider the list complete with those individuals, but I can't assume that. (He doesn't mention Richard Feynman.) To make it clear that he meant to include those and no others, the writer could have said, "The founding fathers of quantum mechanics were Planck, Bohr, Schrodinger, and Einstein."

By the way, sentences one and two are fine, but I wouldn't use the others.

:)
 

RonBee

Moderator
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Member Type
Other
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
dduck said:
Personally, I think 2 is the best, then 4. I wouldn't use 1.

You would use "Alongside with"? (I don't think I use "alongside" at all.)

:?
 

Abstract Idea

Key Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Portuguese
Home Country
Brazil
Current Location
United States
Which of the following is correct:

1-With Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
2-Alongside Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
3-Alongisde with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
4-Along with Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.

I believe sentence 2 above is the best one. However, I also suggest:
Besides Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, Einstein was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
or
Einstein, besides Planck, Bohr and Schrodinger, was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.

The writer might consider the list complete with those individuals, but I can't assume that. (He doesn't mention Richard Feynman.)

Although R. Feynman bequeathed many invaluable contributions to Physics, he can't be said to be one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics.
Among other contributions he developed an alternative mathematical approach to Quantum Mechanics, the path-integral formalism, but all the main ideas of Quantum Mechanics, as well the traditional approaches, were already ready.

In my view it is appropriate to say the R. Feynman was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Field Theory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top