[Grammar] "If I were you, I would have explained what happened."

[sky3120]

I have found these sentences, "If I were you, I would have enjoyed my vacation.", "If I were you, I would have explained what happened." So I think the structure of "If I were...., I would have p.p..." is also possible. Do you agree with the grammar? I really hope to hear from you again. Thank you so much as usual.

​

 

[bhaisahab]

I have found these sentences, "If I were you, I would have enjoyed my vacation.", "If I were you, I would have explained what happened." So I think the structure of "If I were...., I would have p.p..." is also possible. Do you agree with the grammar? I really hope to hear from you again. Thank you so much as usual.

I would write those as "If I had been you, I would have..."

 

[Raymott]

I have found these sentences, "If I were you, I would have enjoyed my vacation.", "If I were you, I would have explained what happened." So I think the structure of "If I were...., I would have p.p..." is also possible. Do you agree with the grammar? I really hope to hear from you again. Thank you so much as usual.

I think they sound OK as they stand, simply because I think "If I had been you" sounds strange to me. If it were something different like, "If I had been an agent, I would have known about time travel too," I'd use "If I had been ..."

 

[Tdol]

Like Raymott, I would use If I were you there. However, I would not deduce a rule If I were ... I would have pp. It works for If I were you, but it's a special case because I can't be you at you any time. You can't say [strike]If I were there, I would have spoken to her.[/strike]