did good to people of the state or for the people

[ostap77]

Do we do good to somebody or for somebody?

 

[susiedqq]

Depends on what you want to say:

He was good to me so I married him.

That marriage was good for the entire family.

 

[ostap77]

Depends on what you want to say:

He was good to me so I married him.

That marriage was good for the entire family.

Would there be a hint ? I'd say I'm 90% sure I got it. We say that someone is good to us or some thing is good for us?

 

[5jj]

Would there be a hint ? I'd say I'm 90% sure I got it. We say that someone is good to us or some thing is good for us?

No.
My grandson is good for me. He keeps me active in mind and body.

Perhaps in my declining years, when he is older, he will be good to me.

 

[milan2003_07]

"For" usually means that something is done for someone's benefit and brings them something (luck, money, satisfaction, acknowledgement, etc.) "To" normally means direction and indicates that something "goes" from object 1 to object 2. For example:

I bought presents for my mother
I gave a letter to her

In sentence #1 it's obvious that my mother will be happy when she has got her present, whereas in the sentence with "letter" we don't know whether she will be pleased after reading it or vive versa.

 

[MrPedantic]

Do we do good to somebody or for somebody?

1. He did good to the people of the state.
2. He did good for the people of the state.

#1 means that the people of the state were the recipients of the "good".

#2 would mean that he did good on behalf of the people of the state.

#1 would be (I think) the meaning you intend. #2 would be an obscure and much less commonly used formation.

Best wishes,

MrP

 

[probus]

To be good to people is to be benevolent -- you wish them well and try to help them. It is a personal action you take.

He is my nephew and I enjoy being good to him.

To be good for people is to be beneficial. It is not a personal action, but the result of a quality of an object.

Carrots are good for you. Hard work is good for you. It builds strength and character. So is being charitable. It improves your karma.

However, when it comes to _doing_ good as opposed to being good, I think you can only do it for people, not to people.

 

[ostap77]

"For" usually means that something is done for someone's benefit and brings them something (luck, money, satisfaction, acknowledgement, etc.) "To" normally means direction and indicates that something "goes" from object 1 to object 2. For example:

I bought presents for my mother
I gave a letter to her

In sentence #1 it's obvious that my mother will be happy when she has got her present, whereas in the sentence with "letter" we don't know whether she will be pleased after reading it or vive versa.

I would assume you didn't understand the question. I'm not talking about prepositions in general. I specifically meant the context given in my first post.

 

[5jj]

I would assume you didn't understand the question. I'm not talking about prepositions in general. I specifically meant the context given in my first post.

I would assume that milan did understand your question. I would also assume that you did not understand that his post was an attempt to make a general, helpful, observation.