Do we need to say "by" or "from" here?

[tufguy]

To an insurance representative: Do you see another claim "by a different" doctor or "from a different" doctor?

Do we need to say "by" or "from" here?

 

[teechar]

Explain what you mean. Are doctors making the claims?

 

[tufguy]

Explain what you mean. Are doctors making the claims?

No, this is what ussualy said.

 

[teechar]

No, this is what is usually said.

By who, to who, and for what?

 

[Tdol]

Is the doctor backing a claim by making a diagnosis of illness or injury? If so, I'd ask whether there has been a second medical opinion.

 

[tufguy]

By who, to who, and for what?

By employees that work for a doctor whose claims have to be followed up on to insurance representatives.

 

[tufguy]

Is the doctor backing a claim by making a diagnosis of illness or injury? If so, I'd ask whether there has been a second medical opinion.

Did you ask whether he is helping(does backing mean helping here)? If so ofcourse he is.

 

[emsr2d2]

Did you ask Are you asking whether he is helping space here (does "backing" mean "helping" here)? If so, of space here course he is.

"Backing" here means "supporting". If someone makes a claim, particularly for a medical cost, the insurance might require a doctor to "back" (or "back up") that claim in some way. I'm not entirely convinced that that's what the original sentence (even a grammatical version) would mean. I would take it to mean "Have you seen any evidence of another claim (from the same patient) from a different doctor"?

Can you explain the situation in which you want to use the sentence you attempted in post #1?

 

[tufguy]

"Backing" here means "supporting". If someone makes a claim, particularly for a medical cost, the insurance might require a doctor to "back" (or "back up") that claim in some way. I'm not entirely convinced that that's what the original sentence (even a grammatical version) would mean. I would take it to mean "Have you seen any evidence of another claim (from the same patient) from a different doctor"?

Can you explain the situation in which you want to use the sentence you attempted in post #1?

At my office. If there are two claims by two different doctors then insurance usually pays only one.

 

[Tdol]

How do they make multiple claims for the same thing?

 

[emsr2d2]

If they're trying to defraud the system by putting in two claims for one thing, I'm surprised the insurance companies even pay out for one of them. Both claims should be denied and their insurance policies should be cancelled. That's usually the result of fraud.

 

[tufguy]

If they're trying to defraud the system by putting in two claims for one thing, I'm surprised the insurance companies even pay out for one of them. Both claims should be denied and their insurance policies should be cancelled. That's usually the result of fraud.

Please answer my question.

 

[Tdol]

Your question doesn't make much sense to us- how can there be two claims? If so, in this country, they would try to establish which claim was legitimate.