KEN JPN
Junior Member
- Joined
- May 27, 2012
- Member Type
- Retired English Teacher
- Native Language
- Japanese
- Home Country
- Japan
- Current Location
- Philippines
Tense Agreement
I strongly doubt Tense Agreement, because all the following sentences are correct and actually used.
1, She said she was a teacher of our school.
2, She said she is a teacher of our school.
3, He said the meeting would be on Sunday.
4, He said the meeting will be on Sunday.
1: If "she said" five years ago, it would be natural to say "she was" because whether she is still a teacher of our school is unknown.
2: However, if "she said" so only yesterday, I would naturally think "she is" still a teacher of our school even today. In that case, I feel odd if I say "She said she was..".
3: If he called me two years ago and told "The meeting will be on Sunday," that Sunday meeting should have been finished when I say this.
So, "at the moment he called me, the meeting WOULD be on Sunday.
4: However, if he just called me now and said, "The meeting will be on Sunday," and hung up. I would turn to my friend beside me and say, "He said the meeting will be on Sunday."
School grammar says, "The only exception of Tense Agreement is a universal truth, like "He told me that the sun rises in the east.".
But if I take Tense Agreement as a rule, I chronically have to meet so many 'exceptions' .
Instead, if I believe "the tense of a predicate verb is always determined separately only in the reference to the present time," I do not find any exceptions.
Is Tense Agreement still believed and taught even to English natives?
(Here, I am talking about only predicative, not including subjunctive or conditional.)
Thanks in advance.
I strongly doubt Tense Agreement, because all the following sentences are correct and actually used.
1, She said she was a teacher of our school.
2, She said she is a teacher of our school.
3, He said the meeting would be on Sunday.
4, He said the meeting will be on Sunday.
1: If "she said" five years ago, it would be natural to say "she was" because whether she is still a teacher of our school is unknown.
2: However, if "she said" so only yesterday, I would naturally think "she is" still a teacher of our school even today. In that case, I feel odd if I say "She said she was..".
3: If he called me two years ago and told "The meeting will be on Sunday," that Sunday meeting should have been finished when I say this.
So, "at the moment he called me, the meeting WOULD be on Sunday.
4: However, if he just called me now and said, "The meeting will be on Sunday," and hung up. I would turn to my friend beside me and say, "He said the meeting will be on Sunday."
School grammar says, "The only exception of Tense Agreement is a universal truth, like "He told me that the sun rises in the east.".
But if I take Tense Agreement as a rule, I chronically have to meet so many 'exceptions' .
Instead, if I believe "the tense of a predicate verb is always determined separately only in the reference to the present time," I do not find any exceptions.
Is Tense Agreement still believed and taught even to English natives?
(Here, I am talking about only predicative, not including subjunctive or conditional.)
Thanks in advance.