gwada
Member
- Joined
- May 3, 2016
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- French
- Home Country
- France
- Current Location
- France
Hello,
I am having trouble figuring out whether the use of WHO is mandatory in the following sentence:
"The heroes are students (WHO are) all very different. Still, they have to get along because they sing together in the school choir."
Could the part in bold be omitted? (Such as in sentences like: "The man (who is) in the street is not my brother")
I would feel uncomfortable doing so, because "different" is an adjective. So it has to work either as epithet, or attributive. But I am not sure that I am right about that.
To me, omitting that part in the first sentence would only be possible this way:
"The heroes are students, all of them very different. Still, they have to..."
Thanks for helping me out.
Have a nice day.
I am having trouble figuring out whether the use of WHO is mandatory in the following sentence:
"The heroes are students (WHO are) all very different. Still, they have to get along because they sing together in the school choir."
Could the part in bold be omitted? (Such as in sentences like: "The man (who is) in the street is not my brother")
I would feel uncomfortable doing so, because "different" is an adjective. So it has to work either as epithet, or attributive. But I am not sure that I am right about that.
To me, omitting that part in the first sentence would only be possible this way:
"The heroes are students, all of them very different. Still, they have to..."
Thanks for helping me out.
Have a nice day.