-
Is this grammatically correct?
I've been working on understanding grammatical syntax, especially on more complex sentences. Is this sentence grammatically correct?
In this sense, I find it peculiar that I recognize the personalities which populate this community because I am but a specter peering in.
---
The rest is simply breaking down the syntax of the sentence.
[INTRODUCTORY PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE], [INDEPENDENT CLAUSE] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 1 CONNECTED BY RELATIVE PRONOUN SERVING TO MODIFY INDEPENDENT CLAUSE] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 2 CONNECTED BY A RELATIVE PRONOUN SERVING TO MODIFY DEPENDENT CLAUSE 1] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 3 CONNECTED BY A SUBORDINATING CONJUNCTION SERVING TO SIGNAL A REASON WHY]
In this sense = Introductory Prepositional Phrase
(References previous sentence)
I find it peculiar = Independent Clause
-I = Subject
-find = main verb/predicate
-it = indirect object (Referencing subsequent clause)
-peculiar = direct object
That I recognize the personalities = Dependent Clause
-That = Relative Pronoun introducing dependent clause functioning as an adjective
-I = subject
-Recognize = verb/predicate
-The - definite article
- personalities = direct object
Which populate this community = Dependent Clause
-Which = Relative pronoun introducing dependent clause functioning as an adjective (used in the place of “that” to avoid repetition)
-the subject is "populations" from previous clause
-populate = verb/predicate
-this = demonstrative pronoun
-community = direct object
I am but a specter peering in = Dependent Clause
-Even though = Subordinating conjunction
-But = adverb modifying am
-a = indefinite article
-specter peering in = subject complement
-specter = noun
-peering in = verbal phrase acting as a modifying of "specter"
-peering = present participle
-in = preposition
-
Re: Is this grammatically correct?
Well, this reads like an undergraduate assignment in syntax.
However, the quoted sentence sounds awkward and I doubt that anyone would actually say it that way.
-
Re: Is this grammatically correct?

Originally Posted by
Mac Flecknoe
I've been working on understanding grammatical syntax, especially on more complex sentences. Is this sentence grammatically correct?
In this sense, I find it peculiar that I recognize the personalities which populate this community because I am but a specter peering in.
---
The rest is simply breaking down the syntax of the sentence.
[INTRODUCTORY PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE], [INDEPENDENT CLAUSE] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 1 CONNECTED BY RELATIVE PRONOUN SERVING TO MODIFY INDEPENDENT CLAUSE] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 2 CONNECTED BY A RELATIVE PRONOUN SERVING TO MODIFY DEPENDENT CLAUSE 1] [DEPENDENT CLAUSE 3 CONNECTED BY A SUBORDINATING CONJUNCTION SERVING TO SIGNAL A REASON WHY]
In this sense = Introductory Prepositional Phrase
(References previous sentence)
I find it peculiar = Independent Clause
-I = Subject
-find = main verb/predicate
-it = indirect object (Referencing subsequent clause)
-peculiar = direct object
That I recognize the personalities = Dependent Clause
-That = Relative Pronoun introducing dependent clause functioning as an adjective
-I = subject
-Recognize = verb/predicate
-The - definite article
- personalities = direct object
Which populate this community = Dependent Clause
-Which = Relative pronoun introducing dependent clause functioning as an adjective (used in the place of “that” to avoid repetition)
-the subject is "populations" from previous clause
-populate = verb/predicate
-this = demonstrative pronoun
-community = direct object
I am but a specter peering in = Dependent Clause
-Even though = Subordinating conjunction
-But = adverb modifying am
-a = indefinite article
-specter peering in = subject complement
-specter = noun
-peering in = verbal phrase acting as a modifying of "specter"
-peering = present participle
-in = preposition
In what sense? It needs to be preceded by something, it makes no sense as it is.
-
Re: Is this grammatically correct?

Originally Posted by
bhaisahab
In what sense? It needs to be preceded by something, it makes no sense as it is.
I just took it out of a paragraph I was writing and broke it down. I was wondering if all the dependent clauses heaped on top of each other was grammatically correct.
-
Re: Is this grammatically correct?
I find it peculiar. "it" is the direct object (not indirect). "Peculiar" cannot be a direct object
or any other kind, because it is an adjective qualifying "it"
Similar Threads
-
By Unregistered in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 29-Sep-2008, 01:30
-
By ccone in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 5
Last Post: 15-Jul-2008, 01:30
-
By rachelmichelle in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 23-Jun-2008, 04:50
-
By KLPNO in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 29-May-2008, 17:34
-
By KLPNO in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 24-Apr-2008, 23:33
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1