5Likes -
He can grasp!
A teacher is saying this about his student. Is it correct?
I want to know how much can he grasp?
-
Re: He can grasp!

Originally Posted by
RoseSpring
A teacher is saying this about his student. Is it correct?
I want to know how much can he grasp?
I want to know; how much can he grasp? (Some may use a comma instead of the semi-colon)
I want to know how much he can grasp?
-
Re: He can grasp!
Just a minor point, but neither are questions.
-
Re: He can grasp!

Originally Posted by
billmcd
Just a minor point, but neither are questions.
You are right for the second one, my mistake. But for the first one, I'd like to know your opinion. Because I think it needs a question mark.
I want to know; how much can he grasp?
I want to know how much he can grasp.
-
Re: He can grasp!
No, neither statement is a question and therefore no question mark, even though a question is indirect and implied and it would possibly generate a response from the listener. If the statement were simply, "How much can he grasp? then, of course, it is question.
-
-
Re: He can grasp!

Originally Posted by
billmcd
No, neither statement is a question and therefore no question mark, even though a question is indirect and implied and it would possibly generate a response from the listener. If the statement were simply, "How much can he grasp? then, of course, it is question.
Thanks indeed, I usually got confused in such matter. Thanks for help.
-
Re: He can grasp!

Originally Posted by
euncu
I want to know; how much can he grasp?
I want to know how much he can grasp.

Originally Posted by
billmcd
Neither statement is a question and therefore no question mark, even though a question is indirect and implied and it would possibly generate a response from the listener. If the statement were simply, "How much can he grasp? then, of course, it is question.
If the first one is not a question, how do you justify the inversion of the auxiliary?
-
Re: He can grasp!
Regardless of whether the auxiliary is inverted in the examples and use of a semicolon, it remains an implied question that does not require a question mark. Further, from a grammatical perspective "to know how much can he grasp" qualifies as an infinitive phrase that is the object of "wants". And finally, the sentence structure in the first example, while not terribly bad, is a little awkward.
-
Re: He can grasp!

Originally Posted by
billmcd
Regardless of whether the auxiliary is inverted in the examples and use of a semicolon, it remains an implied question that does not require a question mark. Further, from a grammatical perspective "to know how much can he grasp" qualifies as an infinitive phrase that is the object of "wants". And finally, the sentence structure in the first example, while not terribly bad, is a little awkward.
So you mean that the first (awkward) example is grammatically correct irrespective of the auxiliary inversion?
I want to know; how much can he grasp.
I want to know; how much he can grasp.
Just to confirm, are the sentences above, although a little awkward, both correct?
Similar Threads
-
By Abstract Idea in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 29-Dec-2009, 13:12
-
By Deepurple in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 2
Last Post: 03-Oct-2008, 13:08
-
By thedaffodils in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 9
Last Post: 05-Aug-2008, 12:10
-
By changeling in forum General Language Discussions
Replies: 2
Last Post: 23-Jul-2008, 17:04
-
By mayclaire in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 8
Last Post: 14-Mar-2007, 15:08
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1