Word substitution and substitute. How to use them correctly.

[michael281001]

For this dish on the menu, the chicken can be substituted with other kind of meat such as beef and fish. So i asked the customer:
1) What would like to substitute this dish with/for? or what meat would like to substitute this meat with/for?
2) Which one of this dish you would like to substitute or which one of this dish you would like to make substitution?

[Rover_KE]

'Would you like that with chicken, beef or fish?'

Rover