7Likes -
reported speech
I have three questions about the following sentence. Please help.
I thougt that next time I would not (stop to run?) stop running(,?) even when I become (became?) tired.
Thank you
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
ndexter
I have three questions about the following sentence. Please help.
I thougt that next time I would not (stop to run?) stop running(,?) even when I become (became?) tired.
Thank you
I decided that next time, I would not stop running even when I became tired.
I'm confused as to why your thread is entitled "Reported speech" when the question has nothing to do with reported speech.
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
emsr2d2
I'm confused as to why your thread is entitled "Reported speech" when the question has nothing to do with reported speech.
Why not?
It's the same structure.
He said (that) he decided that next time, he would not stop running even when he became tired.
Even if you left out "He said (that)", it still would be the same structure.
Cheers!
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
Nightmare85
Why not?
It's the same structure.
He said (that) he decided that next time, he would not stop running even when he became tired.
Even if you left out "He said (that)", it still would be the same structure.
Cheers!
"He said that he had decided..."
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
Nightmare85
Why not?
It's the same structure.
He said (that) he decided that next time, he would not stop running even when he became tired.
Even if you left out "He said (that)", it still would be the same structure.
Cheers!
Hmmmmm. So "reported thought"!
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
emsr2d2
Hmmmmm. So "reported thought"!

I think that it is kind of "self-reported speech/thought".
Direct thought/speech:
Next time I will not stop running even when I become tired.
Self-reported thought/speech:
I thought (decided) that next time I would not stop running even when I became tired.
I was not sure about "became". Even now, I don't quite understand it.
In direct speech, I'm talking about something in the future. Right?
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
ndexter
I think that it is kind of "self-reported speech/thought".
Direct thought/speech:
Next time I will not stop running even when I become tired.
Self-reported thought/speech:
I thought (decided) that next time I would not stop running even when I became tired.
I was not sure about "became". Even now, I don't quite understand it.
In direct speech, I'm talking about something in the future. Right?
Let's make it easier.
Direct speech:
Mike: Next time when I become tired, I will not stop running.
Reported speech:
Mike said that next time when he become (became) tired, he would not stop running.
In direct speech, "become" is related to the future.
Could anyone please explain how backshift works here?
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
emsr2d2
Hmmmmm. So "reported thought"!

Useless post is useless...
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
ndexter
Let's make it easier.
Direct speech:
Mike: Next time when I become tired, I will not stop running.
Reported speech:
Mike said that next time when he become (became) tired, he would not stop running.
In direct speech, "become" is related to the future.
Could anyone please explain how backshift works here?
"Mike said that next time when he becomes tired, he won't stop running".
-
Re: reported speech

Originally Posted by
ndexter
Let's make it easier.
Direct speech:
Mike: Next time when I become tired, I will not stop running.
Reported speech:
Mike said that next time when he become (became) tired, he would not stop running. becomes tired he will not stop running.
Although it is a habit that many people follow, there is no good reason to change tense in reported speech. In fact, changing tense often causes ambiguity of meaning.
2006
Similar Threads
-
By Unregistered in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 18-Nov-2008, 13:39
-
By easygoing in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 08-Nov-2008, 19:58
-
By louhevly in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 07-Jan-2008, 00:55
-
By Mad-ox in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 2
Last Post: 27-Jun-2007, 17:16
-
By blacknomi in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 11
Last Post: 03-Dec-2004, 17:20
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1