# the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago

• 28-Jan-2012, 15:53
azhu
the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago
1.Unless I'm mistaken , the plane _____ an hour ago.
(A) has been arrived
(B) arrived
(D) has arrived

Why not D?

In my (very) vague memory, my teacher has told us that when describing the arrive or leaving of trains/ships/planes, use simple past instead of past perfect. Is this the reason why the answer should be B?
• 28-Jan-2012, 16:00
5jj
Re: the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago
Quote:

Originally Posted by azhu
Why not D? Because 'an hour ago' locates the arrival clearly in the past.

In my (very) vague memory, my teacher has told us that when describing the arriveal or leaving departure of trains/ships/planes, we use simple past instead of past perfect. Is this the reason why the answer should be B?

It's nothing to do with arrivals and departures; it is to do with how we locate the action in time. The following are all correct:

The train has left, so we'll have to catch the next one.
The train left an hour ago.
The train had left by the time John got to the station.

Our train was leaving as we got to the platform.
• 28-Jan-2012, 18:02
billmcd
Re: the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago
Quote:

Originally Posted by azhu
1.Unless I'm mistaken , the plane _____ an hour ago.
(A) has been arrived
(B) arrived
(D) has arrived

Why not D?

In my (very) vague memory, my teacher has told us that when describing the arrive or leaving of trains/ships/planes, use simple past instead of past perfect. Is this the reason why the answer should be B?

As 5jj has indicated the tense in your example has nothing to do with arrivals/departures. "Wht not D ?" Because one of the uses of the present perfect is for past actions whose time is not definite and therefor "has arrived" and "an hour ago" are not comatible.
• 28-Jan-2012, 23:05
billmcd
Re: the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago
Quote:

Originally Posted by billmcd
As 5jj has indicated the tense in your example has nothing to do with arrivals/departures. "Wht not D ?" Because one of the uses of the present perfect is for past actions whose time is not definite and therefor "has arrived" and "an hour ago" are not comatible.

Sorry, should have been "compatible".
• 29-Jan-2012, 03:45
azhu
Re: the plane "arrived" or "has arrived" an hour ago
Quote:

Originally Posted by 5jj
It's nothing to do with arrivals and departures; it is to do with how we locate the action in time. The following are all correct:

The train has left, so we'll have to catch the next one.
The train left an hour ago.
The train had left by the time John got to the station.

Our train was leaving as we got to the platform.

Thank you very much for explaining reason why, giving more examples, and correcting my errors! X-)
I completely understand now.:-D

Billmcd, thank you very much, too!

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.1