Present Perfect versus Past Simple

Here are two situations in the classroom:

1) a student made a mistake in his paper that he had turned in three days ago and the teacher is talking about it in class
2) a student has just made a mistake in class

How shall I phrase the following idea in both situations so that the sentences would be grammatically correct:

I am glad you made (have made) a mistake - you gave (have given) me a chance to teach you!
:?:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by englishhobby

Here are two situations in the classroom:

1) a student made a mistake in his paper that he had turned in three days ago and the teacher is talking about it in class
2) a student has just made a mistake in class

How shall I phrase the following idea in both situations so that the sentences would be grammatically correct:

I am glad you made (have made) a mistake - you gave (have given) me a chance to teach you!
:?:

---

"I am glad you have made a mistake - you have given me a chance to teach you!"
This works in both contexts.

Thank you!