-
Re: persuade to do / persuade into doing
You've misinterpreted my 'regional' comment, Doc. That was intended to include possible regional differences in AmE. My input here was intended as just that: input.
.
It's interesting to know that some people do say "persuade into".
-
Re: persuade to do / persuade into doing

Originally Posted by
Philly
You've misinterpreted my 'regional' comment, Doc. That was intended to include possible regional differences in
AmE. My input here was intended as just that: input.
.
It's interesting to know that some people do say "persuade into".
Yes, but with a slightly different meaning. Some people might think that in some cases you can use gerund or infinitive and still make the same meaning as with start to work/working. In reality gerund always implies: looking back on experience. Comapre like:
I like to do sth (choice)
I like doing sth (enjoyment: experience)
-
Re: persuade to do / persuade into doing
I'm not sure I catch a necessary connotation of extra effort in "persuade into": I take the "into" as metaphorically directional. Cf.
1. I persuaded the rabbit into the hutch.
This suggests some waving of dandelion leaves in front of the twitching pink nose; but not necessarily in any kind of sustained fashion.
MrP
-
Re: persuade to do / persuade into doing

Originally Posted by
MrPedantic
I'm not sure I catch a necessary connotation of extra effort in "persuade into": I take the "into" as metaphorically directional. Cf.
1. I persuaded the rabbit into the hutch.
This suggests some waving of dandelion leaves in front of the twitching pink nose; but not necessarily in any kind of sustained fashion.
MrP
With respect, I don't think that example's quite fair. The 'into' we're talking about (in the phrasal verb 'persuade into') is the first of the two in your sentence (which only has one, I know!):
I persuaded the rabbit [into going] into the hutch.
I think you'd only use the fuller form of that sentence if the first effort (simple chasing) failed, a second attempt (with bran) failed too, but only dandelion leaves had the desired effect.
b
PS
Is this an entirely teacher-led thread now?
Last edited by BobK; 01-Feb-2007 at 15:28.
-
Re: persuade to do / persuade into doing
I don't know about teacher-led; but I do worry that we're giving the impression of knowing far too much about luring rabbits into hutches.
Must remember to choose an example that involves spark plugs, sprockets, and brake clutch levers next time...
MrP
Similar Threads
-
By gdiamond in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 4
Last Post: 27-Jun-2006, 10:55
-
By jiang in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 2
Last Post: 10-Mar-2005, 07:43
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1