4Likes -
1 Post By BobK -
1 Post By 5jj -
2 Post By Tdol
-
ye olde
How would you pronounce "ye" in this name? I am interested in learning whether the etymologically justified pronunciation survives. When a person knows that this pronunciation is /ðiː/ or /ðə/, do they usually pronounce the word this way? (Of couse, they will rarely have reason to say it, but what would they choose if they had to?)
-
Re: ye olde
Last edited by DontBanMe; 06-Jul-2011 at 08:23.
-
Re: ye olde

Originally Posted by
DontBanMe
Thank you, but it doesn't really help. I already knew what is written there. I would like to know how people pronounce it.
-
Re: ye olde

Originally Posted by
birdeen's call
Thank you, but it doesn't really help. I already knew what is written there. I would like to know how people pronounce it.
There's a button you can click.
But I think the compilers have been tempted by their knowledge to make more of an elision than I am used to hearing. The pronunciation on that page is almost a monosyllable; whereas the version I commonly hear is /ji: ɒldi:/ (sometimes without the final /i:/).
I'm not a fan of 'sounds like' statements (as, if the example is already mispronounced, then the new word will perpetuate the same mispronunciation); but in this case I feel justified as many people feel there's a link between this sort of 'ye' and the archaic 2nd person plural 'ye' - "They're both archaic so who cares about the difference in meaning? It's the same word.' Of course, it's not.)
b
-
Re: ye olde

Originally Posted by
BobK
There's a button you can click.
But I think the compilers have been tempted by their knowledge to make more of an elision than I am used to hearing. The pronunciation on that page is almost a monosyllable; whereas the version I commonly hear is /ji: ɒldi:/ (sometimes without the final /i:/).
I'm not a fan of 'sounds like' statements (as, if the example is already mispronounced, then the new word will perpetuate the same mispronunciation); but in this case I feel justified as many people feel there's a link between this sort of 'ye' and the archaic 2nd person plural 'ye' - "They're both archaic so who cares about the difference in meaning? It's the same word.' Of course, it's not.)
b
Thanks. Do you ever hear the /ðiː/ pronunciation? Different dictionaries give different information on this, so I'm note sure what the truth is. If you heard someone use this pronunciation, would you find them pretentious?
-
Re: ye olde

Originally Posted by
BobK
I think the compilers have been tempted by their knowledge to make more of an elision than I am used to hearing. The pronunciation on that page is almost a monosyllable; whereas the version I commonly hear is /ji: ɒldi:/ (sometimes without the final /i:/).
I agree.
I have never heard the /ðiː/ pronunciation.
I would consider it pretentious and/or silly. As far as I am concerned, this mock olde worlde word is 'ye', pronounced /ji:/
-
Re: ye olde

Originally Posted by
birdeen's call
Thanks. Do you ever hear the /ðiː/ pronunciation? Different dictionaries give different information on this, so I'm note sure what the truth is. If you heard someone use this pronunciation, would you find them pretentious?
I have only ever heard /j/. If someone used /ð/, it would be hard to know what the spelling was.
Similar Threads
-
By jzerusi in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 11-Mar-2008, 16:22
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1