Is ING necessary in these sentences?

Status
Not open for further replies.

venilson

New member
Joined
Apr 16, 2020
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Portuguese
Home Country
Brazil
Current Location
Brazil
Teacher, I would like to know what is the appropriate way to say these sentences.

''without even trying'' and ''without first being understood'' X ''without even try'' and ''without first be understood''

I know that we have to use the verb with ING form after a preposition, but ''even'' and ''first'' are not a preposition, so why we have to use ''trying'' and ''being'' instead of using ''even try'' or ''first be understood''.
The full sentence is:
1º '' Be with someone who makes you smile without even trying''
2° ''Nothing can be enjoyed or hated without first being understood''

Thank you so much!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. Be with someone who makes you smile without even trying.
2. Nothing can be enjoyed or hated without first being understood.

Without is to be followed by an noun, not a verb (without doing something, not without do something). The noun is a gerund in the above sentences.
 
The inclusion of the word even between the preposition and the -ing makes no difference to the rule, venilson.
 
Teacher, I would like to know the appropriate way to say these sentences is.

''Without even trying'' and ''without first being understood'' X ''without even try'' and ''without first be understood''

Those are not sentences.

I know that we have to use the verb with ING form after a preposition, but ''even'' and ''first'' are not prepositions, so why do we have to use ''trying'' and ''being'' instead of using ''even try'' or ''first be understood"?

The full sentence is:

1º ''[no space]Be with someone who makes you smile without even trying.'' To make that a sentence, use a period.

2° ''Nothing can be enjoyed or hated without first being understood.'' Ditto.

Thank you so much! Use just one exclamation point.
You're welcome!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top