outside my means

Status
Not open for further replies.

keannu

VIP Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
What does this "outside my means" mean? Beyond my property?

mo3-46
I grew up in a small town in northern California, between wide-open ranchland and dark forests, feeling at home in two places: the wild land and books. I read constantly, hungrily, and without direction, collecting a strange stew of facts and ideas about the rest of the world. I longed for a world away from what I knew and outrageously outside my means. One morning I came across a catalog for a college preparatory school called Billups Academy. It had a summer program and offered scholarships for high school students to ‘deepen and extend their intellectual, aesthetic, and moral interests.’ I applied for and won a scholarship. Billups wasn’t just another school
 
It means 'more than I could afford (to pay for).'
 
It's strange that keannu suggested 'beyond' as part of his alternative. BNC has no instances of 'outside + <possessive> + means' but 28 instances of 'beyond + <possessive> + means'.

As the subject matter here is American, I thought COCA might tell a different story. But not so:

1 BEYOND THEIR MEANS 78
2 BEYOND THE MEANS 53 [BobK: followed by 'of']
3 BEYOND OUR MEANS 33
4 BEYOND HIS MEANS 27
5 BEYOND ITS MEANS 17
6 BEYOND YOUR MEANS 12
7 BEYOND MY MEANS 7
8 BEYOND HER MEANS 6
...
There are only 7 cases of other uses of 'beyond * means'. Coincidentally 7 is the total number of COCA hits for 'outside * means'.

In short, in both Br Eng and Am Eng, 'beyond' is better. Possibly, the geographical context being California, there is a Hispanic tendency in either the writer or the local dialect of English:'outside my means' could be (just my guess) a word-for-word translation of fuera de mis medios.

b
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top