[Grammar] Why is the subject omitted in this adverbial clause?

Status
Not open for further replies.

registered

Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
My teacher told us we can omit the clause's subject, when it consists with the main clause's subject.

Does my GPA matter when applying for a job?

my GPA
is the main clause's subject, but the adverbial clause omit I am.
In this sentence, the subject in the clause doesn't consists with the subject in the main clause.How can "I am" be omit?
 
Your sentence is correct. It would also be correct with "I am" added. The subject does not have to be the same.
 
I saw a cow riding my bicycle through the countryside the other day.
 
I saw a cow riding my bicycle through the countryside the other day.
It's not the same case.riding my bicycle is the object complement describing the cow.
 
Your sentence is correct. It would also be correct with "I am" added. The subject does not have to be the same.
Could you please give me some more examples?
 
'I usually stay indoors while raining.'
 
Last edited:
That sentence doesn't work, Matthew.
 
'I usually stay indoors while raining.'

That suggests that you are raining!

I usually stay indoors while reading.
I usually stay indoors when it rains.
I usually stay indoors during rain.
 
I think that was the point, Matthew seems to be doing what I did: providing a sentence that illustrates the issue of slight to moderate to severe changes in subject with multiple clauses -- meaning "this sort of practice can really be problematic, see?"
 
Of course not! I think we are discussing the grammar problem.
 
That suggests that you are raining!

I usually stay indoors while reading.
I usually stay indoors when it rains.
I usually stay indoors during rain.

Is this sentence right? "Does my GPA matter when applying for a job? "
 
Is this sentence right? "Does my GPA matter when applying for a job? "
It's grammatical. I don't like it though.
I think the meaning you're after is, "Does one's GPA matter when one is applying for a job?" or "Does your GPA matter when you're applying for a job?" Here the "your" means "one's", ie. it's non-specific.
The original is a very unnatural sentence. I really don't think many people would say it. I would say (if this is what I meant), "Does my GPA matter when I'm applying for a job?" It depends on how clearly you want to speak.
 
Is this sentence right? "Does my GPA matter when applying for a job? "

I think you should keep "I am" in that sentence. That way you wouldn't have to explain what you mean.
 
I saw a cow riding my bicycle through the countryside the other day.

"riding my bicycle through the countryside the other day" is a hanging participle and not placed near "I", the subject of the main clause which is "I saw a cow" thus failing to make the sentence clear. It should rather be like that: "When riding my bicycle through the countryside the other day, I saw a cow."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top