There is a book called the god delusion by Richard Dawkins and I was wondering why there is no s possessive, the god's delusuion? also why is there the definite article the?
Thank you![]()
the noun god functions as an adjective to the noun delusion, modifying it
God does not have any delusions. But we have something called "the god delusion"; that is, we believe in a supernatural being and that is a delusion, according to the book.
EDIT: in response to Barb's post -- the above is a description of the book's content;
Last edited by freezeframe; 08-Apr-2011 at 18:49.
The above post was a perfect description of the GRAMMAR.
Comments about that actual existence, non-existence, or nature of God are neither sought nor welcome.
I'm not a teacher, but I write for a living. Please don't ask me about 2nd conditionals, but I'm a safe bet for what reads well in (American) English.
When you put two nouns together, the first one functions as an adjective. This has nothing to do with god as such.
Leather pants -- pants made out of leather; not the same as "pants' leather"
Letter opener -- opener for letters; not the same as "opener's letter"
god delusion -- delusion that god exists; not the same as "god's delusion", which would mean "god is delusional".
For that matter, we normally capitalize "God" when referring to the Judeo-Christian, monotheistic God (as opposed to, say, Greek or Roman gods.)
I am describing the common usage that I am familiar with. If others choose differently, that is their prerogative. I thought a learner of the language should know that it can be considered disrespectful to not capitalize "God."
If we can tell learners that many prefer gender neutral words like "firefighter" over "fireman," in order to avoid offending some people, we can surely tell them what the norm is on this subject.
Style and Editing Guide
This is a digest of the AP stylebook. Searching under "Capitalization" shows the recommendation that "God" be capitalized.